Sign up for Premera Bluecross Policy 7.01.605 alerts
Get alerted when Policy 7.01.605 changes without checking for updates manually.
Monitor payer policy activity
Receive email alerts as soon as relevant payer policies are published or updated.
This policy governs when open shoulder arthrotomy procedures, including decompression/acromioplasty, rotator cuff repair, distal clavicle resection, dislocation procedures, and synovectomy, may be considered medically necessary. It applies to providers submitting these services for coverage.
Policy Summary
PayerPremera Bluecross
PolicyShoulder Open Procedures
Policy CodePolicy 7.01.605
Change TypeModified
Effective DateSeptember 4, 2026
Last ReviewMay 12, 2026
Next Review DateNot specified
Key ActionDocument three months of failed medication management and at least six weeks of physical therapy or directed home exercise when required for the applicable open shoulder procedure.
OpenPayer is powered by Trek Health's payer performance platform. Trek continuously ingests, validates, and normalizes Transparency in Coverage data alongside payer policies and other commercial payer data to create a structured payer intelligence foundation. OpenPayer uses this foundation to deliver personalized search results, dynamically generated policy pages, and tailored policy monitoring based on each user's payers, specialties, billing codes, and areas of interest. The same intelligence powers broader payer performance workflows, including reimbursement benchmarking, contract evaluation, payer negotiations, and financial decision-making.
POLICY UPDATE CHANGES
Conservative management requirements were revised for specified indications to require both a medication trial and failure and a trial and failure of physical measures.
Additional testing requirements were added for decompression of the subacromial space or acromioplasty for rotator cuff tendonitis, full-thickness rotator cuff repair, distal clavicle resection, and shoulder dislocation.
Criteria were deleted for multiple indications, including AC separation after a recent traumatic event, shoulder pain, deformity, partial-thickness rotator cuff repair, loose body or osteochondral lesion removal, specified recurrent or initial dislocations, fracture repair, and shoulder hardware removal.
Eleven CPT codes were removed from the policy and CPT 23770 was removed because it is not a valid code.
The policy title was changed from 'Shoulder Arthrotomy in Adults' to 'Shoulder Open Procedures in Adults' and subsequently to 'Shoulder Open Procedures.'
5Indication groups with revised trial requirements
4Additional testing requirement groups
12Indication categories with deleted criteria
11CPT codes removed
18Listed shoulder procedure CPT codes
Medical Necessity Criteria
Acromioclavicular (AC) Separation
Shoulder arthrotomy for acromioclavicular (AC) separation may be considered medically necessary when ALL of the following criteria are met:
ALL of the following
ONE or more is present
Recent traumatic event
Shoulder pain
Deformity
Rockwood type III or higher injury diagnosed by imaging
X-ray is the imaging gold standard. MRI may be used for soft-tissue assessment or when X-ray is inconclusive; ultrasound is not typically used to grade AC separation.
Subacromial Decompression or Acromioplasty
Shoulder arthrotomy for decompression of the subacromial space or acromioplasty for rotator cuff tendonitis may be considered medically necessary when ALL of the following criteria are met:
ALL of the following
History of disabling shoulder pain with loss of shoulder function that interferes with activities of daily living (ADLs)
At least ONE positive orthopedic test on physical examination compared with the non-affected shoulder
Hawkins-Kennedy Impingement Test
Neer Impingement Test
Non-steroidal anti-inflammatories (NSAIDs)
Full-Thickness Rotator Cuff Repair
Shoulder arthrotomy for full-thickness rotator cuff repair may be considered medically necessary when ALL of the following criteria are met:
ALL of the following
History of disabling shoulder or upper-arm pain with loss of shoulder function that interferes with ADLs
Shoulder pain or weakness on resisted abduction or rotation
At least ONE positive orthopedic test is present
Drop-arm test
Painful arc test
Empty-can test (Jobe test)
Resection of Distal Clavicle for AC-Joint Arthritis
Shoulder arthrotomy for resection of the distal clavicle for AC-joint arthritis may be considered medically necessary when ALL of the following criteria are met:
ALL of the following
History of disabling shoulder pain with loss of shoulder function that interferes with ADLs
Localized tenderness to palpation of the AC joint
At least ONE positive orthopedic test on physical examination compared with the non-affected shoulder
Cross-body adduction test (Scarf test/Cross-over adduction test)
Resisted AC-joint extension test
Initial Shoulder Dislocation
Shoulder arthrotomy with or without capsulorrhaphy for an initial shoulder dislocation may be considered medically necessary when ALL of the following criteria are met:
ALL of the following
History of shoulder dislocation or subluxation with disabling shoulder pain and loss of shoulder function that interferes with ADLs
At least ONE positive orthopedic test or sign demonstrates instability
Anterior or posterior apprehension test
Load-and-shift test
Sulcus sign
MRI demonstrates at least ONE of the following
Major or Complete Synovectomy
Shoulder arthrotomy for major or complete synovectomy may be considered medically necessary when ALL of the following criteria are met:
ALL of the following
ONE or more symptoms is present
Joint pain
Locking
Pain with range of motion (ROM)
Limited ROM
Crepitus (crackling or crunching sounds in a joint)
Medical Necessity for Shoulder Open Procedures
The following shoulder open procedures in adults are considered medically necessary only for the specified indications and when the applicable policy criteria are met:
Covered indications when applicable criteria are met
Acromioclavicular (AC) separation
Decompression of the subacromial space or acromioplasty for rotator cuff tendonitis
Full-thickness rotator cuff repair
Resection of the distal clavicle for AC-joint arthritis
Initial shoulder dislocation repair, with or without capsulorrhaphy
This medical policy does not apply to Medicare Advantage.
Documentation and coverage criteria for initial shoulder dislocation repair should support ALL of the following:
ALL of the following
History of shoulder dislocation or subluxation with disabling shoulder pain and loss of shoulder function that interferes with ADLs
Any of the following positive orthopedic tests or signs demonstrates instability
Anterior or posterior apprehension test
Load-and-shift test
Sulcus sign
MRI demonstrates at least ONE of the following
Major or Complete Synovectomy — Documentation Requirements
Documentation for major or complete shoulder synovectomy should support ALL of the following:
ALL of the following
ONE or more symptoms is present
Joint pain
Locking
Pain with ROM
Limited ROM
Crepitus
Other Indications or Situations
Not medically necessary
The indication or situation is not listed or described in the policy, or the applicable policy criteria are not met.
All indications not listed or other situations not described in this policy, including when policy criteria are not met, are considered not medically necessary.
Procedure Coding
Decompression of subacromial space or acromioplastyCPTCovered
Medication examplesNSAIDs, acetaminophen, or an appropriate corticosteroid injection
Physical therapy or directed home exercise
Required durationAt least 6 weeks
Documentation and Submission Guidance
Documentation Required
Initial Shoulder Dislocation Repair
For initial shoulder dislocation repair, submit documentation showing the qualifying history, instability findings, MRI evidence, and required conservative-treatment trial. The record must support all applicable criteria before submission.
History of shoulder dislocation or subluxation with disabling shoulder pain and loss of shoulder function interfering with activities of daily living (ADLs).
Instability on physical examination demonstrated by an anterior or posterior apprehension test, load-and-shift test, or sulcus sign.
MRI demonstrates a labral lesion consistent with clinical instability (such as a Bankart lesion), Hill-Sachs lesion, capsular tear, or capsular redundancy with clinical multidirectional instability.
Documentation Required
Major or Complete Synovectomy
For major or complete shoulder synovectomy, document the qualifying symptoms, objective pathology, failed conservative treatment, and an eligible underlying diagnosis. All required elements must be supported in the clinical record.
Clinical Background
A shoulder arthrotomy is an open surgical incision into the shoulder joint used to directly diagnose or treat significant shoulder pathology when less-invasive approaches, such as imaging or arthroscopy, are insufficient. Depending on the condition, it may address infection, injury, instability, tendon damage, joint disease, or synovial pathology. Because recovery may be longer than with less-invasive approaches, postoperative physical therapy may be required.
Clinical Terms and Examination Findings
Shoulder arthrotomy
ProcedureAn open surgical incision into the shoulder joint
Joint involvedTypically the glenohumeral joint
UsesDiagnostic exploration, removal of intra-articular loose bodies, or treatment of structural instability
Type II or III acromion
Type IIA curved acromion
Type IIIA hooked acromion
Clinical significanceThese shapes can reduce space for the rotator cuff tendons and bursa and contribute to subacromial impingement
Policy Summary
PayerPremera Bluecross
PolicyShoulder Open Procedures
Policy CodePolicy 7.01.605
Change TypeModified
Effective DateSeptember 4, 2026
Last ReviewMay 12, 2026
Next Review DateNot specified
Key ActionDocument three months of failed medication management and at least six weeks of physical therapy or directed home exercise when required for the applicable open shoulder procedure.
Subacromial corticosteroid injection, as appropriate
Trial and failure of physical measures: physical therapy (PT) and/or directed home exercise for at least 6 weeks
Plain X-rays or imaging (MRI or CT) demonstrate findings consistent with subacromial impingement, such as a Type II or Type III acromion
Type II acromion is curved and Type III acromion is hooked; these shapes can reduce the space available for the rotator cuff tendons and bursa.
Weakness of external rotation (lag/dropping sign)
Imaging demonstrates a partial- or full-thickness rotator cuff tear; chronic tears may be associated with muscle atrophy, fatty replacement, or tendon retraction
NSAIDs
Acetaminophen
Subacromial corticosteroid injection, as appropriate
Trial and failure of physical measures: PT and/or directed home exercise for at least 6 weeks
Conservative management is not required for an acute traumatic injury with a complete tear, debilitating pain, and loss of function.
NSAIDs
Acetaminophen
AC-joint corticosteroid injection, as appropriate
Trial and failure of physical measures: PT and/or directed home exercise for at least 6 weeks
Plain X-rays or imaging (MRI or CT) demonstrate findings consistent with AC-joint arthritis
Labral lesion consistent with clinical instability, such as a Bankart lesion
Hill-Sachs lesion
Capsular tear (thickening and edema of the joint)
Capsular redundancy with clinical multidirectional instability (the shoulder-joint capsule is loose or stretched)
NSAIDs
Acetaminophen
Intra-articular corticosteroid injection
Trial and failure of physical measures: PT and/or directed home exercise for at least 6 weeks
ONE of the following conditions is present
Irreducible shoulder dislocation
Anterior shoulder instability in a competitive contact or collision athlete
Joint effusion or swelling
Imaging or biopsy demonstrates underlying pathology consistent with the reported medical condition, such as synovitis or joint effusion
NSAIDs
Acetaminophen
Intra-articular corticosteroid injection, as appropriate
Trial and failure of physical measures: PT and/or directed home exercise for at least 6 weeks
Confirmed diagnosis of ONE of the following conditions
Inflammatory arthritis (rheumatoid arthritis, gout, psoriatic arthritis, or pseudogout)
Hemochromatosis (iron overload)
Hemophilia
Lyme synovitis
Non-specific synovitis, including proliferative synovitis or postoperative synovitis from shoulder replacement
Pigmented villonodular synovitis (PVNS)
Recurrent hemarthrosis secondary to sickle cell anemia or bleeding diathesis
Synovial chondromatosis
Major or complete synovectomy
Labral lesion consistent with clinical instability, such as a Bankart lesion
Hill-Sachs lesion
Capsular tear (thickening and edema of the joint)
Capsular redundancy with clinical multidirectional instability
Three months of failed non-operative, conservative management, including a trial of one or more of NSAIDs, acetaminophen, or intra-articular corticosteroid injection
Trial and failure of PT and/or directed home exercise for at least 6 weeks
Joint effusion or swelling
Imaging or biopsy demonstrates underlying pathology consistent with the reported medical condition, such as synovitis or joint effusion
Three months of failed non-operative, conservative management, including a trial of NSAIDs, acetaminophen, or intra-articular corticosteroid injection, as appropriate
Trial and failure of PT and/or directed home exercise for at least 6 weeks
Diagnosis of ONE of the following conditions is present
Inflammatory arthritis (rheumatoid arthritis, gout, psoriatic arthritis, or pseudogout)
Hemochromatosis
Hemophilia
Lyme synovitis
Non-specific synovitis
Pigmented villonodular synovitis (PVNS)
Recurrent hemarthrosis secondary to sickle cell anemia or bleeding diathesis
Synovial chondromatosis
Physical measures
Physical therapy and/or directed home exercise
RequirementA trial of the physical measures must be documented
AC separation severity
Coverage thresholdRockwood type III or higher
Required supportDiagnosis by imaging
Imaging standardX-ray is the imaging gold standard; MRI may assess soft tissue or be used when X-ray is inconclusive
Conservative medication management
Required duration3 months
Applicable proceduresInitial shoulder dislocation repair and major or complete synovectomy
Medication examplesNSAIDs, acetaminophen, or an appropriate intra-articular corticosteroid injection
Physical therapy or directed home exercise
Required durationAt least 6 weeks
Physical measuresPhysical therapy and/or directed home exercise
DocumentationDocument a trial before the applicable open procedure
At least one qualifying symptom: joint pain, locking, pain with range of motion, limited range of motion, crepitus, joint effusion, or swelling.
Imaging or biopsy demonstrates pathology consistent with the reported condition, such as synovitis or joint effusion.
Documentation supports the required medication and physical-treatment trial and confirms one eligible diagnosis, such as inflammatory arthritis, hemochromatosis, hemophilia, Lyme synovitis, nonspecific synovitis, PVNS, recurrent hemarthrosis secondary to sickle cell disease or bleeding diathesis, or synovial chondromatosis.
Unsupported block type: documentation
Unsupported block type: step_therapy
Documentation Required
Acromioplasty or Subacromial Decompression
For acromioplasty or subacromial decompression for rotator cuff tendinitis, document all required symptoms, examination findings, failed conservative treatment, and imaging evidence. The documentation should establish subacromial impingement and functional impairment.
History of disabling shoulder pain with loss of shoulder function interfering with ADLs.
At least one positive examination finding compared with the unaffected shoulder: Hawkins-Kennedy impingement test or Neer impingement test.
Three months of failed conservative management, including an applicable medication trial and PT and/or directed home exercise for at least 6 weeks.
Plain x-rays, MRI, or CT demonstrate findings consistent with subacromial impingement, such as a Type II or Type III acromion.
Documentation Required
Full-Thickness Rotator Cuff Repair
For full-thickness rotator cuff repair, submit documentation establishing disabling symptoms, objective examination findings, imaging-confirmed tearing, and the required conservative-treatment history. Document all elements that apply to the patient’s presentation.
History of disabling shoulder or upper-arm pain with loss of shoulder function interfering with ADLs.
Shoulder pain or weakness with resisted abduction or rotation and tenderness over the rotator cuff.
At least one positive test: drop-arm, painful-arc, empty-can (Jobe), or weakness of external rotation (lag/dropping sign).
Imaging demonstrates a partial- or full-thickness rotator cuff tear; chronic tears may include muscle atrophy, fatty replacement, or tendon retraction.
Document the required three-month medication trial and PT and/or directed home exercise for at least 6 weeks, unless an acute traumatic complete tear causes debilitating pain and loss of function.
Documentation Required
Distal Clavicle Resection
For distal clavicle resection for AC-joint arthritis, document the required symptoms, localized examination findings, positive AC-joint testing, conservative-treatment failure, and imaging.
Disabling shoulder pain with loss of shoulder function interfering with ADLs and localized tenderness to palpation of the AC joint.
At least one positive test compared with the unaffected shoulder: cross-body adduction (Scarf/cross-over adduction) or resisted AC-joint extension.
Three months of failed conservative management with an applicable medication or AC-joint corticosteroid injection and PT and/or directed home exercise for at least 6 weeks.
Plain x-rays, MRI, or CT demonstrate findings consistent with AC-joint arthritis.
Documentation Required
Initial Shoulder Dislocation
For initial shoulder dislocation repair, document the dislocation or subluxation history, functional impact, and objective instability findings. These clinical findings must be paired with the required MRI evidence and treatment history.
History of shoulder dislocation or subluxation with disabling shoulder pain and loss of shoulder function interfering with ADLs.
Positive anterior or posterior apprehension test, load-and-shift test, or sulcus sign demonstrating instability.
MRI evidence of a qualifying lesion, including a Bankart or other clinically consistent labral lesion, Hill-Sachs lesion, capsular tear, or capsular redundancy with multidirectional instability.
Documentation Required
Major or Complete Synovectomy: Qualifying Findings
For major or complete synovectomy, document at least one qualifying symptom or finding and link it to the underlying shoulder pathology. The record should make the clinical indication clear.
Qualifying symptoms or findings include joint pain, locking, pain with ROM, limited ROM, crepitus, joint effusion, or swelling.
Document the duration, severity, and functional effect of the reported symptom or finding.
Support the condition with imaging or biopsy and identify the confirmed eligible diagnosis.
The initial shoulder dislocation repair submission must include the clinical evidence supporting medical necessity, not just the procedure request. Ensure the history, examination, imaging, and conservative-treatment documentation are internally consistent.
Include the dislocation or subluxation history and disabling pain with loss of function interfering with ADLs.
Record the positive instability test or sign and the MRI finding that explains the clinical instability.
Include documentation of three months of failed conservative management, including an applicable medication trial and PT and/or directed home exercise for at least 6 weeks.
Documentation Required
Synovectomy Documentation
For synovectomy, submit documentation connecting symptoms to objective pathology, failed conservative management, and a qualifying diagnosis. Imaging or biopsy and treatment records should be included or clearly referenced.
Document one or more qualifying symptoms: pain, locking, pain with ROM, limited ROM, crepitus, effusion, or swelling.
Provide imaging or biopsy evidence of underlying pathology consistent with the reported condition.
Document three months of failed treatment with NSAIDs, acetaminophen, and/or an appropriate intra-articular corticosteroid injection, plus PT and/or directed home exercise for at least 6 weeks.
Identify one qualifying diagnosis: inflammatory arthritis, hemochromatosis, hemophilia, Lyme synovitis, nonspecific synovitis, PVNS, recurrent hemarthrosis related to sickle cell disease or bleeding diathesis, or synovial chondromatosis.
Denial Risk
Unlisted Indication or Unmet Criteria
Shoulder arthrotomy procedures are not medically necessary for indications not listed in the policy or when the applicable criteria are not met. Verify the indication and every required criterion before submission to reduce denial risk.
Unlisted indications and other situations not described in the policy are considered not medically necessary.
Failure to document required symptoms, examination findings, imaging, eligible diagnosis, or conservative-treatment trials may result in non-coverage.
Pigmented villonodular synovitis
ConditionPigmented villonodular synovitis (PVNS)
Tissue involvedSynovial tissue
DefinitionA rare condition involving overgrowth of cells within synovial tissue
Acromioplasty
ProcedureRemoval of part of the acromion bone
PurposeCreate more space for rotator cuff tendon movement
Expected effectReduce impingement-related pain and inflammation
Anterior apprehension test
PurposeAssess anterior shoulder instability
PositionThe arm is abducted to 90 degrees and slowly externally rotated while the humeral head is pushed anteriorly
Positive resultA sense of impending shoulder dislocation
Anterior glenoid rim fracture
InjuryA break at the front edge of the glenoid cavity
Typical causeTraumatic shoulder dislocation
AssociationJoint instability
Bankart lesion
InjuryA tear of the anteroinferior glenoid labrum
Typical causeAnterior shoulder dislocation
AssociationRecurrent joint instability
Capsulorrhaphy
ProcedureSurgical stabilization of a loose or unstable shoulder joint
TechniqueTightening the shoulder capsule and ligaments to reduce excessive movement
ApproachMay be performed through an open surgical technique or arthroscopically
Cofield classification of full-thickness rotator cuff tears
SmallLess than 1 cm
Medium1–3 cm
Large3–5 cm
MassiveGreater than 5 cm
Crank test
PurposeAssess for glenoid labral tears, particularly SLAP tears
ManeuverThe abducted arm is compressed and the humerus is rotated
Positive resultPain or clicking associated with a labral tear is reproduced
Cross-body adduction test
PurposeAssess potential acromioclavicular joint injury, arthritis, or subluxation
ManeuverThe arm is passively adducted across the body, compressing the AC joint
Positive resultPain with the maneuver
Drop arm test
PurposeIdentify a significant rotator cuff tear, particularly involving the supraspinatus
ManeuverThe examiner raises the arm to 90 degrees and removes support
Positive resultThe arm drops, cannot be held at 90 degrees, or cannot be lowered smoothly
Ellman classification of partial-thickness rotator cuff tears
Grade 1Less than 3 mm deep
Grade 23–6 mm deep
Grade 3Greater than 6 mm deep
Empty can test
PurposeAssess supraspinatus function
ManeuverThe arms are abducted to 90 degrees with thumbs pointing down while the examiner applies downward pressure
Positive resultPain, weakness, instability, or dropping of the affected arm
Hawkins-Kennedy impingement test
PurposeAssess subacromial impingement syndrome
ManeuverThe arm is flexed to 90 degrees and passively internally rotated