Loading...

    Explore
    • Policy Monitoring
    • Live Policy Feed
    • Billing Codes
    • Healthcare Providers
    • Health Insurance Payers
    • States
    • Service Lines
    • Taxonomy Codes
    Lookup tools
    • Billing Code Lookup
    • CPT Modifier Lookup
    • Provider Taxonomy Code Lookup
    • Healthcare Provider & Facility Lookup
    • Health Insurance Payer Lookup
    • Payer Contact Directory

    Policy & Benchmark Tools

    • Prior Authorization Lookup
    • Coverage Criteria Lookup
    • Timely Filing Lookup
    • Billing Code Reimbursement Rates
    • Payer Comparison Dashboard
    • Facility Comparison Dashboard
    • All tools

    Company

    • About OpenPayer
    • Data Sources
    • Request a Policy / Feedback
    • Trek Health
    OpenPayerby Trek Health
    LinkedInYouTube

    © 2026 Trek Health. All rights reserved.

    OpenPayer is built and maintained by Trek Health.

    v1.0.31
    OpenPayerBilling CodesRepair, Revision, and/or Reconstruction Procedures on the ShoulderCPT cpt-23412-open-rotator-cuff-repair-shoulder
    Ask Trek AI about this page

    CPT 23412: Open Repair of Chronic Rotator Cuff Tear

    Medicare pays $806 and commercial payers pay $3111 on average nationally for this procedure.

    CPT code 23412 describes an open surgical repair of a chronic or persistent rotator cuff tear in the shoulder; the service is an orthopedic surgical procedure typically performed in an operating room or ambulatory surgery center to restore rotator cuff integrity and shoulder function.

    For related coverage guidance, see recent payer policy updates: Surgical Site of Care - Hospital Outpatient, Dental Anesthesia Services, Dental Anesthesia Services.

    Customize your policy alerts

    Sign up for cpt 23412 policy alerts

    Get alerted when payer policies referencing 23412 are released or updated.

    Monitor payer policy activity

    Receive email alerts as soon as relevant payer policies are published or updated.

    National Reimbursement Benchmarks

    National means show Medicare at $806.1 versus BUCA (commercial aggregate) at $3,111.3, indicating BUCA’s average reimbursement is roughly four times Medicare’s. That gap highlights a common commercial-to-Medicare divergence: Medicare centers near mid-range public-sector payment while commercial aggregates like BUCA sit substantially higher, affecting overall market pricing benchmarks.

    Dispersion measured by the interquartile range (P75–P25) varies notably: Blue Cross Blue Shield has the widest IQR at $5,118.1 ($6,910.3–$1,792.2), followed by BUCA at $3,298.7 ($4,607.0–$1,308.3). UnitedHealth Group’s IQR is $902.5 ($1,883.5–$981.0) and Cigna’s is $980.0 ($1,846.0–$867.0). Aetna is the tightest among those with full quartiles at $714.0 ($878.0–$141.2). These spreads indicate where commercial contract rates cluster tightly versus where they are highly variable.

    Table of contents

    Progress1 / 9

    Explore openpayer tools

    • Billing CodesCPT, HCPCS, DRG & more
    • Reimbursement RatesCommercial vs. Medicare rate reports
    • Facility ComparisonBeds, revenue & payer mix
    • ProvidersHospitals & facilities
    • PayersPlans & market footprint
    • Taxonomy CodesNUCC specialty codes
    • ModifiersCPT modifiers & usage
    • Prior AuthorizationPA policies by payer & drug
    • Timely FilingFiling deadlines by payer
    • Coverage CriteriaMedical necessity by payer
    • Payer ContactsClaims, PA & appeals contacts
    View all tools
    National Payer Mean Reimbursement Rates

    State Reimbursement Rates

    State: Alaska1 / 51

    Rate by payer

    Clinical & Coding Specifications

    Clinical Context

    A 62-year-old recreational gardener presents with progressive right shoulder pain and weakness for 9 months after insidious onset. Conservative care including physical therapy, nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs, and corticosteroid injection provided limited relief. MRI demonstrates a chronic, full-thickness tear of the supraspinatus tendon consistent with a chronic rotator cuff tear. The orthopaedic surgeon schedules an open rotator cuff repair to mobilize and reattach the tendon to the greater tuberosity.

    Preoperative workflow includes history and physical, anesthesia evaluation, informed consent with discussion of risks/benefits, preoperative imaging review, and optimization of comorbidities. On the day of surgery the patient receives regional block or general anesthesia, operative site preparation, and sterile draping. The surgeon performs an open deltoid-splitting approach, debrides chronic tendon margins, prepares the greater tuberosity footprint, and repairs the tendon with anchors and sutures. A concurrent partial acromioplasty may be performed if indicated. Postoperative workflow includes recovery from anesthesia, discharge instructions, pain management, and referral for structured rehabilitation with immobilization followed by progressive range-of-motion and strengthening over months.

    Typical site of service: Ambulatory surgery center or hospital outpatient surgical unit. Service type: Open orthopaedic surgical repair of a chronic rotator cuff tear.

    Related CPT Codes

    CPT CodeDescriptionRelationship to This Procedure
    23130

    Related Modifiers

    12 rows

    ModifierDescriptionWhen to Use
    26Modifier 26 (Professional Component) identifies and bills only the professional portion of a split service — the physician’s interpretation, report, and medical judgment — when the technical…- Use CPT Modifier -26 when you are billing only the professional component (PC) of a split‑bill eligible service—i.e., you performed the physician interpretation, medical judgment and prepared a…
    50Modifier –50 (Bilateral Procedure) is appended to a CPT code when an identical procedure is performed on paired anatomical structures during the same operative session. The AMA states to add…- Use modifier -50 when the same CPT surgical, diagnostic, or radiology procedure is performed on paired anatomical structures (both sides of the body) during the same operative/session by the same…
    51Modifier –51 (Multiple Procedures) is used when the same provider performs multiple procedures in the same session to identify secondary, non‑exempt procedures and indicate payment reduction logic…- Use modifier -51 when the same provider performs multiple distinct procedures during the same patient encounter: report the highest‑valued procedure first (no modifier) and append -51 to…
    52Modifier ‑52 (Reduced Services) indicates that a service or procedure was partially reduced or omitted at the provider’s discretion, allowing reporting of the basic procedure number with a qualifier…- Use modifier -52 when a physician or qualified health professional electively reduces or omits part of a procedure or service (for example, performing fewer required views or omitting a portion of…
    53Modifier 53 (Discontinued Procedure) signals that a surgical or diagnostic service was begun by the physician but terminated because of extenuating circumstances that threatened the patient’s…- Use modifier -53 when a physician/qualified healthcare professional has started a surgical or diagnostic procedure (e.g., anesthesia administered, incision or scope insertion) and then discontinues…
    59Modifier 59 indicates a distinct procedural service when two procedures that are not normally billed together are clinically and procedurally separate. The CPT definition (as reiterated by CMS)…- Use modifier -59 to report a distinct procedural service when documentation supports that the procedure reported is not normally billed together with another service on the same day because of a…
    62Modifier 62 indicates that two surgeons function as co‑surgeons, each performing distinct parts of the same primary surgical procedure. It is appended to the primary procedure code (and any…- Use modifier -62 when two surgeons act as co‑surgeons (both primary surgeons) on a single definitive primary procedure, each performing distinct parts of the same surgical procedure (append -62 to…
    66Modifier 66 (Surgical Team) is used when three or more surgeons act as primary surgeons on a single, highly complex procedure. The AMA defines it for use when a surgical team — often composed of…- Use modifier 66 when three or more surgeons act as primary surgeons working collaboratively as a surgical team on a single, highly complex or difficult procedure (for example organ…
    78CPT modifier -78 indicates an unplanned, related return to the operating or procedure room by the same provider during the global postoperative period. It is appended when treatment for a…- Use modifier -78 when an unplanned, related complication during the original procedure’s global postoperative period requires the patient to return to a formal operating or procedure room and the…
    79Modifier 79 indicates a surgical procedure performed during the postoperative global period of a prior surgery that is unrelated to the original procedure. Per AMA/CPT and CMS guidance, it is…- Use modifier 79 when the same physician (or same‑specialty physician in the same group) performs a surgical procedure during the postoperative global period of a prior surgery and the new procedure…

    Showing 1–10 of 12

    Related Provider Taxonomies

    8 rows

    Taxonomy Code
    207X00000X
    207XS0117X
    207XX0004X
    261QM1200X
    103TH0100X
    246ZS0410X
    282NW0100X
    163WE0900X

    Related ICD-10-CM Codes

    24 rows

    ICD-10-CM CodeDescription
    M19.011Primary osteoarthritis, right shoulder
    M19.012Primary osteoarthritis, left shoulder
    M24.211Disorder of ligament, right shoulder
    M24.212Disorder of ligament, left shoulder
    M24.221Disorder of ligament, right elbow
    M24.222Disorder of ligament, left elbow
    M25.111Fistula, right shoulder
    M25.112Fistula, left shoulder
    M25.121Fistula, right elbow
    M25.122Fistula, left elbow

    Showing 1–10 of 24

    Related Payer Policy Updates

    Specialty: Anesthesiology1 / 3

    10 rows

    PolicyPayerEffective Date
    Surgical Site of Care - Hospital Outpatientregence2026-11-01
    Dental Anesthesia ServicesProvidence Health Plan2026-10-01
    Dental Anesthesia ServicesProvidence Health Plan2026-10-01
    Anesthesia Services for Interventional Pain Management Procedures in an AdultCigna2026-09-15
    General Anesthesia and Conscious Sedation ServicesUnitedHealthcare2026-09-01
    Intravenous Anesthetics for the Treatment of Chronic Pain and Psychiatric or Substance Use DisordersPremera Bluecross2026-07-01
    Intravenous Anesthetics for the Treatment of Chronic Pain and Psychiatric or Substance Use DisordersPremera Bluecross2026-07-01
    Intravenous Anesthetics for the Treatment of Chronic Pain and Psychiatric or Substance Use DisordersPremera Bluecross2026-07-01
    Intravenous Anesthetics for the Treatment of Chronic Pain and Psychiatric or Substance Use DisordersPremera Bluecross2026-07-01
    Elective Inpatient Services (for Idaho Only)UnitedHealthcare2026-06-01

    Related Codes

    CPT-23395-MUSCLE-TRANSFER-SHOULDER-UPPER-ARM-RECONSTRUCTION

    CPT 23395: Muscle Transfer to Shoulder or Upper Arm

    CPT-23397-MULTIPLE-MUSCLE-TRANSFER-SHOULDER-UPPER-ARM-RECONSTRUCTION

    CPT 23397: Multiple Muscle Transfer to Shoulder or Upper Arm

    CPT-23400-SCAPULAR-FIXATION-RECONSTRUCTION-SPRENGEL-DEFORMITY

    CPT 23400: Scapulodesis for Shoulder Asymmetry

    CPT-23405-SHOULDER-TENOTOMY-TENDON-RELEASE

    CPT 23405: Shoulder Tenotomy, Single Tendon

    CPT-23406-SHOULDER-MULTIPLE-TENOTOMY

    CPT 23406: Multiple Tenotomy of Shoulder

    CPT-23410-OPEN-ROTATOR-CUFF-REPAIR-SHOULDER

    CPT 23410: Open Repair of Acute Rotator Cuff Tear

    CPT-23415-CORACOACROMIAL-LIGAMENT-RELEASE-ACROMIOPLASTY

    CPT 23415: Coracoacromial Ligament Release with Acromioplasty

    CPT-23420-SHOULDER-RECONSTRUCTION-ACROMIOPLASTY

    CPT 23420: Complete Shoulder Reconstruction with Acromioplasty

    CPT-23430-BICEPS-TENODESIS-PROXIMAL-HUMERUS

    CPT 23430: Open Biceps Tenodesis, Fixation to Proximal Humerus

    CPT-23440-BICEPS-TENDON-TENODESIS-SHOULDER-STABILIZATION

    CPT 23440: Biceps Tenodesis/Transposition for Shoulder Stability

    Showing 1–10 of 24

    Frequently Asked Questions

    References

    1. 1.CPT® Codes and Descriptions. AAPC. Retrieved Aug 11, 2026.Maintains the CPT code set's official descriptions and guidelines, licensed from the American Medical Association, used as the definitional source for CPT codes on this page.
    2. 2.HCPCS Quarterly Update. Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS). Retrieved Aug 11, 2026.CMS's quarterly release of HCPCS Level II codes and short/long descriptors, the source for HCPCS code definitions and update history.
    3. 3.ICD-10-CM Full Code List. Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS). Retrieved Aug 11, 2026.CMS's complete ICD-10-CM diagnosis code list, used to cross-reference diagnosis codes associated with this procedure or service.
    Published by

    Trek Health powers OpenPayer with a leading commercial payer intelligence platform, seamlessly converting fragmented payer data into actionable insights for provider organizations.

    Trek Health ingests and normalizes Transparency in Coverage data and payer policy updates to give provider organizations a clear view of how commercial reimbursement behaves across markets, payers, and services. Our platform transforms raw payer disclosures into structured intelligence that supports contract evaluation, payer negotiations, and service line strategy. By combining market benchmarks with ongoing policy visibility, Trek helps teams identify variability, risk, and opportunity in commercial reimbursement. The result is faster insight, stronger negotiating positions, and more informed financial decisions.

    Excision procedures on the shoulder (partial acromioplasty or acromionectomy with or without coracoacromial ligament release)
    Commonly performed adjunctive procedure to decompress the subacromial space during rotator cuff repair and address impingement.