Loading...

    Explore
    • Policy Monitoring
    • Live Policy Feed
    • Billing Codes
    • Healthcare Providers
    • Health Insurance Payers
    • States
    • Service Lines
    • Taxonomy Codes
    Lookup tools
    • Billing Code Lookup
    • CPT Modifier Lookup
    • Provider Taxonomy Code Lookup
    • Healthcare Provider & Facility Lookup
    • Health Insurance Payer Lookup
    • Payer Contact Directory

    Policy & Benchmark Tools

    • Prior Authorization Lookup
    • Coverage Criteria Lookup
    • Timely Filing Lookup
    • Billing Code Reimbursement Rates
    • Payer Comparison Dashboard
    • Facility Comparison Dashboard
    • All tools

    Company

    • About OpenPayer
    • Data Sources
    • Request a Policy / Feedback
    • Trek Health
    OpenPayerby Trek Health
    LinkedInYouTube

    © 2026 Trek Health. All rights reserved.

    OpenPayer is built and maintained by Trek Health.

    v1.0.32
    OpenPayerPolicy UpdatesOrthopedics/MusculoskeletalPremera Bluecross Shoulder Open Procedures Coverag…
    Ask Trek AI about this page

    OpenPayer is powered by Trek Health's payer performance platform. Trek continuously ingests, validates, and normalizes Transparency in Coverage data alongside payer policies and other commercial payer data to create a structured payer intelligence foundation. OpenPayer uses this foundation to deliver personalized search results, dynamically generated policy pages, and tailored policy monitoring based on each user's payers, specialties, billing codes, and areas of interest. The same intelligence powers broader payer performance workflows, including reimbursement benchmarking, contract evaluation, payer negotiations, and financial decision-making.

    ModifiedPremera BluecrossPolicy N/A

    Shoulder Open Procedures

    Customize your policy alerts

    Sign up for all Premera Bluecross policy alerts

    Know when Premera Bluecross releases new policies or updates existing guidance.

    Monitor payer policy activity

    Receive email alerts as soon as relevant payer policies are published or updated.

    Defines medical necessity criteria, documentation requirements, and coding guidance for open shoulder arthrotomy procedures (e.g., AC separation repair, acromioplasty, rotator cuff repair, distal clavicle resection, dislocation repair, synovectomy) for Premera Bluecross members/providers.

    Policy Summary
    PayerPremera Bluecross
    PolicyShoulder Open Procedures
    Policy CodePolicy N/A
    Change TypeModified conservative management, added testing, and CPT list revisions
    Effective DateSep 4, 2026
    Last ReviewMay 12, 2026
    Next Review DateN/A
    Key ActionObtain prior authorization and document both a medication trial and a trial of physical measures (with durations) plus any required additional testing before billing listed open shoulder procedure codes.
    SourceLink
    POLICY UPDATE CHANGES

    Policy statements modified conservative management to require where noted for each indication both a medication trial and failure as well as a trial and failure of physical measures for specified indications.

    Policy statements modified to require additional testing for specified indications.

    Several CPT codes were removed from the policy's CPT list and one invalid code was replaced.

    Policy title changed from 'Shoulder Arthrotomy in Adults' to 'Shoulder Open Procedures in Adults' then to 'Shoulder Open Procedures'.

    6+distinct indication groups
    3 monthsconservative management duration
    6 weeksminimum PT trial
    Multipleprocedure codes listed
    11+CPTs listed (initial/revised)

    Coverage Criteria for Open Shoulder Procedures

    Acromioclavicular (AC) separation

    Covered when ALL of the following are met

    AC separation (open repair): One or more of the following symptoms: recent traumatic event OR shoulder pain OR deformity; AND Rockwood type III or higher injury diagnosed by imagingRockwood type III+

    Imaging: X-ray preferred; MRI may be used for soft tissue assessment or if x-ray inconclusive; ultrasound not typically used for grading AC separation

    Decompression / Acromioplasty

    Covered when ALL of the following are met

    Decompression of subacromial space / acromioplasty: History of disabling shoulder pain with loss of shoulder function which interferes with activities of daily living (ADLs); AND at least one positive orthopedic impingement test on physical exam (e.g., Hawkins-Kennedy or Neer); AND documentation of three months of failed non-operative conservative management (trial of NSAIDs, acetaminophen, and/or subacromial corticosteroid injection as appropriate); AND PT and/or directed home exercise for at least 6 weeks; AND plain x-rays or imaging (MRI or CT) demonstrate findings consistent with subacromial impingement (e.g., Type II or III acromion)
    Policy Summary
    PayerPremera Bluecross
    PolicyShoulder Open Procedures
    Policy CodePolicy N/A
    Change TypeModified conservative management, added testing, and CPT list revisions
    Effective DateSep 4, 2026
    Last ReviewMay 12, 2026
    Next Review DateN/A
    Key ActionObtain prior authorization and document both a medication trial and a trial of physical measures (with durations) plus any required additional testing before billing listed open shoulder procedure codes.
    SourceLink
    On This Page
    Coverage Criteria for Open Shoulder ProceduresCoding and Procedure CodesProvider Actions, Prior Authorization, and DocumentationBackground and ScopeDefinitions and Procedural TermsPolicy Revision History and Changes
    3 months conservative care; 6 weeks PT

    Additional diagnostic testing required per policy where indicated

    Full thickness rotator cuff repair

    Covered when ALL of the following are met

    Full-thickness rotator cuff repair: History of disabling shoulder or upper arm pain with loss of shoulder function which interferes with ADLs; AND shoulder pain or weakness on resisted abduction or rotation; AND one positive orthopedic test (drop arm, painful arc, empty can/Jobe, or weakness of external rotation); AND imaging demonstrating partial or full-thickness rotator cuff tear (may be associated with muscle atrophy, fatty replacement, or tendon retraction); AND documentation of three months of failed non-operative conservative management (trial of NSAIDs, acetaminophen, and/or subacromial corticosteroid injection as appropriate) (conservative management not required for acute traumatic complete tear with debilitating pain and loss of function); AND PT and/or directed home exercise for at least 6 weeks3 months (exception acute traumatic complete tear); 6 weeks PT

    See Ellman and Cofield grade classifications in Related Information

    Resection of distal clavicle (AC joint arthritis)

    Covered when ALL of the following are met

    Resection of distal clavicle for AC joint arthritis: History of disabling shoulder pain with loss of shoulder function which interferes with ADLs; AND localized tenderness to palpation of the AC joint; AND at least one positive orthopedic test on physical exam (Cross-Body Adduction/Scarf Test or Resisted AC Joint Extension); AND documentation of three months of failed non-operative conservative management (trial of NSAIDs, acetaminophen, and/or AC joint corticosteroid injection as appropriate); AND PT and/or directed home exercise for at least 6 weeks; AND plain x-rays or imaging (MRI or CT) consistent with AC joint arthritis3 months conservative care; 6 weeks PT

    Additional diagnostic testing required per policy where indicated

    Shoulder dislocation / instability

    Covered when ALL of the following are met

    Shoulder arthrotomy with/without capsulorrhaphy for dislocation/instability: History of shoulder dislocation or subluxation with disabling shoulder pain and loss of shoulder function which interferes with ADLs; AND instability on physical exam demonstrated by anterior or posterior apprehension test OR load and shift OR sulcus sign; AND MRI demonstrating at least one of: labral lesion consistent with instability (e.g., Bankart), Hill-Sachs lesion, capsular tear, or capsular redundancy with multidirectional instability; AND documentation of three months of failed non-operative conservative management (trial of NSAIDs, acetaminophen, and/or intra-articular corticosteroid injection as appropriate); AND PT and/or directed home exercise for at least 6 weeks3 months conservative care; MRI showing instability lesion

    See Related Information for specific orthopedic tests and imaging findings

    Synovectomy (major or complete)

    Covered when EITHER of the following conditions is present

    Synovectomy (major or complete): Irreducible shoulder dislocation OR anterior shoulder instability in competitive contact or collision athletes; AND one or more symptoms such as joint pain, locking, pain with ROM, limited ROM, crepitus, or joint effusion; AND confirmed diagnosis of one of the qualifying conditions (inflammatory arthritis, hemochromatosis, hemophilia, Lyme synovitis, non-specific synovitis, pigmented villonodular synovitis, recurrent hemarthrosis, or synovial chondromatosis)diagnosed synovial condition

    Synovectomy CPTs: 23105, 23106

    Synovectomy (open arthrotomy) criteria

    Covered when ALL of the following are met:

    Synovectomy medical necessity: 1) One or more symptoms: joint pain, locking, pain with range of motion (ROM), limited ROM, crepitus, or joint effusion; 2) Imaging or biopsy demonstrates pathology consistent with the reported condition (e.g., synovitis, joint effusion); 3) Documentation of three months of failed non-operative conservative management (trial of NSAIDs, acetaminophen, and/or intra-articular corticosteroid injection as appropriate); 4) Trial of PT and/or directed home exercise for at least 6 weeks; 5) Diagnosis of ONE qualifying condition: inflammatory arthritis (rheumatoid arthritis, gout, psoriatic arthritis, pseudogout), hemochromatosis, hemophilia, Lyme synovitis, non-specific synovitis, pigmented villonodular synovitis (PVNS), recurrent hemarthrosis, or synovial chondromatosis3 months conservative care; 6 weeks PT

    Document imaging or biopsy and specify qualifying diagnosis in medical record

    Open arthrotomy and open procedure indications

    Covered when ANY of the following high-risk or complex clinical scenarios are present (open approach medically necessary over arthroscopy):

    Open arthrotomy indications: Recurrent anterior instability with critical glenoid bone loss or engaging/off-track Hill-Sachs lesion; OR failed prior arthroscopic stabilization or revision cases requiring direct visualization; OR multidirectional instability unresponsive to conservative care; OR large/massive rotator cuff tears (e.g., L-shaped, >3 cm), complete subscapularis tears, poor tissue quality, or failed arthroscopic rotator cuff repairs; OR intra-articular loose bodies or unexplained intra-articular pathology requiring open exploration; OR high-demand or high-risk patients (contact or overhead athletes, military, manual laborers) where open procedures have demonstrated durable outcomes

    Open approaches favored when anatomical complexity, significant bone loss, or prior failures make arthroscopy insufficient

    Medical necessity — general

    General medical necessity: Shoulder arthrotomy (open procedures) in adults is considered medically necessary for the indications noted when criteria are met.

    See policy for indication-specific criteria and documentation requirements

    Conservative management and testing requirements

    Conditions requiring prior conservative therapy and additional testing

    Required prior care for certain indications: For decompression of subacromial space/acromioplasty for rotator cuff tendonitis, full thickness rotator cuff repair, resection of distal clavicle, shoulder dislocation, and synovectomy: documentation must show both a medication trial and failure AND a trial and failure of physical measures prior to approval; additional diagnostic testing is required for several of these indications

    Typical durations: 3 months overall conservative management and at least 6 weeks of PT/directed home exercise unless exceptions apply

    All indications not listed in this policy, and any situations not explicitly described in the criteria above, including when the specific policy criteria are not met, are considered not medically necessary and may be denied.

    Arthroscopic techniques are preferred for many shoulder conditions. Open procedures that include an arthrotomy are reserved for select nonemergent cases when anatomical complexity, failed prior arthroscopic surgery, surgeon expertise, or other clinical factors make an open approach the medically necessary option.

    Policy history shows that multiple previously listed criteria were removed from the document. Examples of deleted items include criteria for acromioclavicular (AC) separation tied to a recent traumatic event, partial-thickness rotator cuff repair, removal of intra-articular osteochondral lesions or loose bodies, several recurrent dislocation scenarios, initial dislocation with associated fractures, shoulder fracture repair, and hardware removal. These deletions are reflected in the policy history entries.

    Procedures performed for indications that are not listed in this policy, or when the specific medical necessity criteria for a listed indication are not met, are considered not medically necessary and subject to denial.

    The policy history documents that several indication-specific criteria were removed from prior versions of the policy (see history). The removed items include a range of previously listed indications such as select AC separation scenarios, partial-thickness rotator cuff repair, loose body removal, recurrent dislocation variations, fracture repair, and hardware removal, indicating these indications are no longer part of the active policy statements.

    Coding and Procedure Codes

    AC separation CPT codesCPT
    23550Acromioclavicular (AC) separation - open repair (CPT 23550 listed in text as CPT 23550)
    23552Acromioclavicular (AC) separation - open repair (CPT 23552)
    Decompression / AcromioplastyCPT
    23130Decompression of subacromial space or acromioplasty (CPT 23130)
    Full-thickness rotator cuff repair CPTsCPT
    23410Full thickness rotator cuff repair (CPT 23410)
    23412Full thickness rotator cuff repair (CPT 23412)
    23420Full thickness rotator cuff repair (CPT 23420)
    Distal clavicle resection CPTCPT
    23120Resection of distal clavicle (CPT 23120)
    Shoulder dislocation / capsulorrhaphy codesCPT
    23450Shoulder dislocation surgery (CPT 23450)
    23455Shoulder dislocation surgery (CPT 23455)
    23460Shoulder dislocation surgery (CPT 23460)
    23462Shoulder dislocation surgery (CPT 23462)
    23465Shoulder dislocation surgery (CPT 23465)
    23466Shoulder dislocation surgery (CPT 23466)
    23660Shoulder dislocation surgery (CPT 23660)
    23670Shoulder dislocation surgery (CPT 23670)
    23680Shoulder dislocation surgery (CPT 23680)
    Synovectomy codesCPT
    23105Synovectomy, major (CPT 23105)
    23106Synovectomy, complete (CPT 23106)
    Synovectomy and related open shoulder CPTsCPT
    23105Arthrotomy; glenohumeral joint, with synovectomy, with or without biopsy (glenohumeral synovectomy)
    23106Arthrotomy; sternoclavicular joint, with synovectomy, with or without biopsy (sternoclavicular synovectomy)
    23120Claviculectomy, partial (partial clavicle resection)
    23130Acromioplasty or acromionectomy, partial, with or without coracoacromial ligament release
    Open rotator cuff, stabilization, and shoulder treatment CPTsCPT
    23410Repair of ruptured musculotendinous cuff (e.g., rotator cuff) open, acute
    23412Repair of ruptured musculotendinous cuff (e.g., rotator cuff) open chronic
    23420Reconstruction of complete shoulder (rotator) cuff avulsion, chronic (includes acromioplasty)
    23450Capsulorrhaphy, anterior; Putti-Platt procedure or Magnuson type operation
    23455Capsulorrhaphy, anterior; with labral repair (e.g., Bankart procedure)
    23460Capsulorrhaphy, anterior, any type; with bone block
    23462Capsulorrhaphy, anterior, any type; with coracoid process transfer
    23465Capsulorrhaphy, glenohumeral joint, posterior, with or without bone block
    23466Capsulorrhaphy, glenohumeral joint, any type multi-directional instability
    23550Open treatment of acromioclavicular dislocation, acute or chronic
    1–10 of 15
    1/2
    Conservative management duration
    Typical required duration3 months of failed non-operative conservative management (unless acute traumatic complete tear with debilitating pain and loss of function)
    Components of conservative managementTrial of one or more medications (NSAIDs, acetaminophen, and/or appropriate corticosteroid injection)
    Documentation expectationMedical records must document trial and failure of conservative care when required for the indication
    Physical therapy / directed home exercise
    Minimum PT/directed home exercise trialAt least 6 weeks of physical therapy and/or directed home exercise
    When requiredPT/home exercise is required in addition to medication trial for decompression, rotator cuff repair, distal clavicle resection, dislocation, and synovectomy criteria
    DocumentationProvider must document duration and content of PT/home exercise trial in medical records

    Provider Actions, Prior Authorization, and Documentation

    Prior Authorization

    Prior authorization and required medical necessity documentation

    Surgical codes for open shoulder procedures listed in the policy require documentation that the applicable medical necessity criteria are met and may require prior authorization per payer process; include the operative indication and supporting imaging/assessment when submitting for authorization.

    • Document that the specific indication meets policy medical necessity criteria.
    • Include supporting imaging, exam findings, and conservative management trials when requesting authorization.
    Prior Authorization

    Prior authorization required for listed CPTs

    Prior authorization is required/associated with the listed CPT codes for open shoulder procedures (arthrotomy, synovectomy, claviculectomy, acromioplasty, open rotator cuff repairs, capsulorrhaphy, open AC treatments, and other listed open shoulder procedures).

    • Obtain prior authorization per payer rules when billing the CPTs listed for open shoulder procedures.
    Billing Rule

    CPT codes affected — obtain authorization when billing

    The policy specifies the CPT codes that will apply when effective; providers should obtain authorization per payer rules when billing these codes and ensure the billed CPT matches the documented operative procedure.

    • Key CPTs called out include (examples): 23105, 23106, 23120, 23130, 23410, 23412, 23420, 23450, 23455, 23460, 23462, 23465, 23466, 23550, 23552, 23660, 23670, 23680, 23929 (see policy for full list).
    • Refer to the policy history for the final effective CPT list and removed codes.
    Documentation Required

    Conservative care documentation required prior to many indications

    Before approval for many indications (decompression/acromioplasty, full-thickness rotator cuff repair, distal clavicle resection, shoulder dislocation, synovectomy), documentation must show prior conservative treatment including medication trial(s) and physical measures as specified by the policy.

    • Medication options cited: NSAIDs, acetaminophen, and where appropriate subacromial or intra-articular corticosteroid injection.
    • Physical measures include PT and/or directed home exercise for the durations specified.
    Step Therapy

    Document trial of conservative therapies (medication + PT)

    Providers should document trials of first-line conservative therapies (NSAIDs, acetaminophen, and intra-articular or subacromial corticosteroid injection as appropriate) and PT/directed home exercise prior to open procedures when indicated.

    • Record duration and response to each medication trial.
    • Document PT/home exercise modality, frequency, and duration.
    Step Therapy

    Conservative management step (medication trial + physical measures) required

    Conservative management requires both a medication trial and failure and a trial and failure of physical measures for specified indications; this combined medication-plus-physical therapy step must be tried and failed prior to approval for those procedures.

    • This dual requirement applies to decompression/acromioplasty, full-thickness rotator cuff repair, resection of distal clavicle, shoulder dislocation, and synovectomy.
    Documentation Required

    Required documentation elements: symptoms, exam, and imaging/testing

    Medical records must document that medical necessity criteria are met for the specific indication, including the patient's symptoms, relevant physical exam findings (positive orthopedic tests), and supporting imaging/testing consistent with the indication.

    • Examples: X-ray preferred for AC separation; MRI when soft tissue assessment is needed; MRI findings for instability (Bankart, Hill-Sachs) for dislocation indications.
    • Include operative indication, positive physical exam tests, and imaging reports when submitting records or authorization requests.
    Documentation Required

    Synovectomy documentation — symptoms plus imaging/biopsy and qualifying diagnosis

    For synovectomy, document the presence of qualifying symptoms (joint pain, locking, pain with ROM, limited ROM, crepitus, or joint effusion) and include imaging or biopsy demonstrating pathology consistent with synovitis or joint effusion.

    • Also document a qualifying diagnosis (e.g., inflammatory arthritis, PVNS, hemochromatosis, hemophilia, Lyme synovitis, recurrent hemarthrosis, synovial chondromatosis).
    • Document trials and failures of conservative care and PT/home exercise where required.
    Documentation Required

    Document trials/failures of medication and physical measures and required testing

    When conservative management is required, providers must document trials and failures of both medication and physical measures (including durations) and any additional testing required by the indication before claim approval or authorization.

    • Typical durations: three months of conservative management overall and at least 6 weeks of PT/directed home exercise unless exceptions apply.
    • Include imaging or other diagnostic testing results when required by the indication (e.g., x-ray, MRI, CT).
    Denial Risk

    Risk of denial for indications not listed or criteria not met

    Procedures for indications not listed in the policy or when the specific criteria are not met are considered not medically necessary and may be denied if submitted without supporting criteria.

    • Do not submit claims for indications not listed in the policy without documented justification meeting policy criteria.
    Denial Risk

    Denial risk for missing conservative management, PT trial, or required testing

    Failure to document required conservative management (three months of failed non-operative conservative care including medication trials and a 6‑week PT/home exercise trial where required) or required additional testing may result in denial.

    • Lack of documentation of three months of failed non-operative management or lack of a 6‑week PT/home exercise trial may trigger denial.
    • Missing required imaging or biopsy evidence for synovectomy or instability-related testing (e.g., MRI showing labral/Hill‑Sachs lesions) may trigger denial.
    Note

    Background and Scope

    Open shoulder arthrotomy is an incision-based surgical approach that provides direct visualization of the glenohumeral joint for diagnosis and treatment of intra-articular pathology. While arthroscopy is preferred when feasible, arthrotomy may be appropriate when open access is required for exploration, removal of loose bodies, treatment of structural instability, significant bone loss, or when prior arthroscopic approaches have failed. Open procedures typically involve a larger incision, direct manipulation of bone, cartilage, tendons, and capsule, and are associated with longer recovery and rehabilitation compared with arthroscopic techniques.

    Definitions and Procedural Terms

    Shoulder arthrotomy — definition
    DefinitionAn open surgical incision into the glenohumeral joint to directly visualize and treat pathology of bones, cartilage, muscles, and other shoulder tissues, used when less invasive methods are insufficient
    Common usesDiagnosis, removal of infected tissue, repair of damage, drainage of joint fluid, and treatment of complex injuries or disease
    Clinical noteOpen arthrotomy typically requires longer recovery and postoperative rehabilitation compared with arthroscopy
    Acromioplasty — definition
    DefinitionRemoval of part of the acromion to increase the subacromial space and relieve impingement by reducing pressure on the rotator cuff
    Indication evidenceImaging (plain x-rays, MRI or CT) demonstrating subacromial impingement (e.g., Type II or III acromion) supports the procedure
    Required prior careDocumentation of three months of failed conservative management and at least 6 weeks of PT/home exercise for coverage when indicated
    Capsulorrhaphy — definition
    DefinitionSurgical tightening of the shoulder capsule and ligaments to stabilize an unstable shoulder, performed via open or arthroscopic technique
    PurposeReduces excessive joint laxity to prevent recurrent dislocation or instability
    Procedural examplesOpen capsulorrhaphy procedures include anterior stabilization techniques (e.g., Putti-Platt, Bankart open repair) described in open procedure CPT listings
    Synovectomy — definition
    DefinitionOpen surgical excision of inflamed synovial tissue from the glenohumeral joint, typically indicated for chronic synovitis unresponsive to conservative treatment
    Qualifying diagnosesIncludes inflammatory arthritis, PVNS, synovial chondromatosis, recurrent hemarthrosis, hemochromatosis, hemophilia, Lyme synovitis, or non-specific synovitis
    Documentation requirementsImaging or biopsy demonstrating synovial pathology plus three months failed conservative care and at least 6 weeks PT/home exercise when required
    Open rotator cuff repair — indications for open approach
    Primary indications for open approachLarge or massive rotator cuff tears (including L-shaped tears), complete subscapularis tears, poor tissue quality, extensive lamination, or previously failed arthroscopic repairs
    RationaleOpen repair provides better access and precision for complex or large tears and may yield superior outcomes in selected cases
    Related evidenceSystematic reviews and cohort studies support open repair for large/massive tears and failed arthroscopic revisions
    Open stabilization procedures — indications
    IndicationsRecurrent anterior instability with critical glenoid bone loss or engaging/off-track Hill-Sachs lesion; significant glenoid bone loss; contact or high-demand athletes; failed prior arthroscopic stabilization or revision cases
    Clinical considerationsOpen stabilization (e.g., Latarjet, open Bankart) favored when bone loss, off-track lesions, or prior arthroscopic failure make arthroscopy insufficient
    Outcomes evidenceRCTs and meta-analyses show open procedures can have lower recurrence and higher return-to-sport in high-risk or revision populations

    Policy Revision History and Changes

    2026-09-04policy_updateLatest

    Effective date for revisions that modified conservative management and testing requirements for multiple indications, removed several CPT codes, replaced an invalid CPT with 23680, and retitled the policy to 'Shoulder Open Procedures'; follows 90-day provider notification.

    2026-06-01interim_review

    Interim review (approved May 12, 2026) documenting removal of numerous CPT codes and replacement of invalid code 23770 with 23680, plus minor formatting corrections and a policy title change to align with intent.

    2025-12-01new_policy

    New policy approved November 11, 2025 and effective for dates of service on or after March 4, 2026; established initial CPT code list and stated that shoulder arthrotomy in adults is medically necessary for listed indications when criteria are met.