Loading...

    Explore
    • Policy Monitoring
    • Live Policy Feed
    • Billing Codes
    • Healthcare Providers
    • Health Insurance Payers
    • States
    • Service Lines
    • Taxonomy Codes
    Lookup tools
    • Billing Code Lookup
    • CPT Modifier Lookup
    • Provider Taxonomy Code Lookup
    • Healthcare Provider & Facility Lookup
    • Health Insurance Payer Lookup
    • Payer Contact Directory

    Policy & Benchmark Tools

    • Prior Authorization Lookup
    • Coverage Criteria Lookup
    • Timely Filing Lookup
    • Billing Code Reimbursement Rates
    • Payer Comparison Dashboard
    • Facility Comparison Dashboard
    • All tools

    Company

    • About OpenPayer
    • Data Sources
    • Request a Policy / Feedback
    • Trek Health
    OpenPayerby Trek Health
    LinkedInYouTube

    © 2026 Trek Health. All rights reserved.

    OpenPayer is built and maintained by Trek Health.

    v1.0.32
    OpenPayerPolicy UpdatesOrthopedics/MusculoskeletalKaiser Permanente Shoulder Policy Update | OpenPay…
    Ask Trek AI about this page
    ModifiedKaiser PermanentePolicy N/A

    Clinical Review Criteria Shoulder Arthroplasty

    Customize your policy alerts

    Sign up for all Kaiser Permanente policy alerts

    Know when Kaiser Permanente releases new policies or updates existing guidance.

    Monitor payer policy activity

    Receive email alerts as soon as relevant payer policies are published or updated.

    This policy governs medical necessity review and authorization for total, reverse, revision, and hemiarthroplasty procedures of the shoulder for Kaiser Foundation Health Plan of Washington members and providers. It applies separate criteria for Medicare and non-Medicare members and includes patient optimization, documentation, and applicable procedure-code requirements.

    Policy Summary
    PayerKaiser Permanente
    PolicyClinical Review Criteria Shoulder Arthroplasty
    Policy CodePolicy N/A
    Change TypeModified
    Effective DateAugust 1, 2026
    Last ReviewJun 9, 2026
    Next Review DateN/A
    Key ActionSubmit prior authorization for the procedure site of service and document that applicable medical-necessity criteria are met.
    SourceLink
    POLICY UPDATE CHANGES

    The inpatient-only list was removed from the revision history.

    Kaiser Permanente adopted its National policy criteria for shoulder arthroplasty.

    5Applicable procedure codes

    OpenPayer is powered by Trek Health's payer performance platform. Trek continuously ingests, validates, and normalizes Transparency in Coverage data alongside payer policies and other commercial payer data to create a structured payer intelligence foundation. OpenPayer uses this foundation to deliver personalized search results, dynamically generated policy pages, and tailored policy monitoring based on each user's payers, specialties, billing codes, and areas of interest. The same intelligence powers broader payer performance workflows, including reimbursement benchmarking, contract evaluation, payer negotiations, and financial decision-making.

    BMI < 40
    Preferred BMI threshold
    HbA1c < 8Diabetes optimization threshold
    30 daysNicotine-free period when applicable
    6 monthsClinical notes requested
    3 monthsPain and functional disability duration

    Medical Necessity Criteria

    Shoulder arthroplasty medical necessity

    Shoulder arthroplasty is medically necessary when ALL applicable criteria are met.

    General requirements

    • Qualifying indication

      • Advanced joint disease

        • Radiographic findings: Positive radiographic findings show shoulder joint destruction, severe joint-space narrowing, severe articular disease on advanced imaging, cystic changes, irregular joint surfaces, glenoid sclerosis, osteophyte changes, a flattened glenoid, or cystic changes of the humeral head.
        • Failed nonoperative treatment: Nonoperative therapy has been tried and failed, including anti-inflammatory medication for at least 3 weeks and a trial of physical therapy within the last 12 months, unless the record clearly documents why conservative therapy is not reasonable.Anti-inflammatory medication ≥ 3 weeks; physical therapy within the last 12 months

          Medication may include oral or topical NSAIDs unless contraindicated, acetaminophen, and/or an appropriate intra-articular corticosteroid injection.

        • Pain and functional impairment: Replacement is needed because of disabling pain for 3 months and functional disability in age-appropriate activities of daily living for 3 months.3 months of disabling pain and 3 months of functional disability
      • Other qualifying indications

        • Osteonecrosis of the humeral head.
        • Reverse total shoulder arthroplasty for a qualifying indication listed in the reverse arthroplasty criteria.
        • Revision replacement of a previous shoulder arthroplasty or hemiarthroplasty for a qualifying failure or complication listed in the revision criteria.
    • Patient optimization: BMI, diabetes, and nicotine/tobacco status meet the policy requirements, or active optimization efforts, risk-based shared decision-making, and any required medical-director review are documented.BMI < 40 preferred; no diabetes or HbA1c < 8; nonsmoker or required nicotine/tobacco cessation status

      BMI > 40 and HbA1c > 8.0 are relative contraindications under the policy.

    Shoulder hemiarthroplasty medical necessity

    Shoulder hemiarthroplasty is medically necessary when ALL applicable criteria are met.

    Hemiarthroplasty requirements

    • Qualifying hemiarthroplasty indication

      • Proximal humerus fracture

        • The fracture has at least one qualifying characteristic listed in the proximal humerus fracture criteria.
      • Advanced joint disease

        • Positive radiographic findings show shoulder joint destruction, severe articular disease on advanced imaging, severe narrowing, erosion, or inadequate glenoid bone stock.
        • Nonoperative therapy has been tried and failed, including anti-inflammatory medication for at least 3 weeks and a trial of physical therapy within the last 12 months, unless the record clearly documents why conservative treatment is not reasonable.

    Proximal humerus fracture indication

    A proximal humerus fracture qualifies for hemiarthroplasty when it has at least one listed fracture characteristic.

    Qualifying proximal humerus fracture

    • Displaced 3-part or 4-part fracture.
    • 3-part or 4-part fracture in osteoporotic bone.
    • Fracture-dislocation.
    • Anatomic neck fracture.
    • Humeral head-splitting or depression fracture.
    • Fracture involving more than 40% of the humeral articular surface.

    Procedure Codes and Clinical Thresholds

    Considered Medically Necessary when applicable policy criteria are metCPTCovered
    23335Removal of prosthesis, includes debridement and synovectomy when performed; humeral and glenoid components (eg, total shoulder).
    23470Arthroplasty, glenohumeral joint; hemiarthroplasty.
    23472Arthroplasty, glenohumeral joint; total shoulder (glenoid and proximal humeral replacement (eg, total shoulder)).
    23473Revision of total shoulder arthroplasty, including allograft when performed; humeral or glenoid component.
    23474Revision of total shoulder arthroplasty, including allograft when performed; humeral and glenoid component.
    BMI
    Preferred thresholdBMI below 40
    When BMI is above 40Document active weight-loss optimization, including sustained weight loss over 3–6 months or stagnant weight despite active participation in a weight-loss or exercise program.
    Additional documentationFormal nutritional counseling and risk-based shared decision-making are required; cases may be reviewed case by case by a medical director.
    HbA1c
    Optimization thresholdNo diabetes, or diabetes with HbA1c below 8.
    Relative contraindicationHbA1c above 8.0 is a relative contraindication.

    Authorization and Documentation Requirements

    Prior Authorization

    Authorize the Procedure and Site of Service

    Prior authorization is required for the procedure and site of service. Submit the request for shoulder arthroplasty, reverse shoulder arthroplasty, hemiarthroplasty, or revision arthroplasty and verify authorization requirements for the specific code and plan type through the Pre-authorization Code Check.

    • Applies to total shoulder, reverse total shoulder, hemiarthroplasty, and revision shoulder arthroplasty.
    • Site-of-service authorization applies to applicable procedures performed in an inpatient hospital, off-campus outpatient hospital, or on-campus outpatient hospital.
    • Applicable codes include CPT 23335, 23470, 23472, 23473, and 23474; codes may not be all-inclusive, and deleted or inactive codes may not be covered.
    Documentation Required

    Document Failed Conservative Treatment

    For applicable advanced joint disease indications, document that required nonoperative treatment was tried and failed before requesting arthroplasty. If conservative treatment was not appropriate, clearly document the clinical reason it was not reasonable or feasible.

    Shoulder Arthroplasty Overview

    Shoulder arthroplasty replaces components of the shoulder joint and may be performed as an anatomic total shoulder arthroplasty, reverse total shoulder arthroplasty, revision arthroplasty, or hemiarthroplasty. Anatomic total shoulder arthroplasty replaces the humeral head and glenoid socket with mechanical components. Reverse total shoulder arthroplasty reverses the normal ball-and-socket configuration by placing the mechanical socket on the humeral head and the ball on the glenoid; it is used for selected complex conditions, including rotator-cuff deficiency, fractures, tumors, inflammatory disease, and other qualifying indications. Revision arthroplasty addresses failure or complications of a prior shoulder arthroplasty or hemiarthroplasty, while hemiarthroplasty replaces the applicable shoulder component and is separately addressed for qualifying fractures, advanced joint disease, osteonecrosis, infection, malignancy, and rotator-cuff-related conditions.

    Procedure Definitions

    Anatomic total shoulder arthroplasty
    DefinitionTraditional anatomic total shoulder arthroplasty replaces the humeral head and the glenoid cup with mechanical components.
    Humeral componentThe head of the humerus, or shoulder “ball,” is replaced with a mechanical component.
    Glenoid componentThe cup of the scapula, or shoulder “socket,” is replaced with a mechanical component.
    Reverse total shoulder arthroplasty
    DefinitionReverse total shoulder arthroplasty reverses the normal ball-and-socket configuration.
    Mechanical socketThe mechanical socket is placed into the head of the humerus.
    Policy Summary
    PayerKaiser Permanente
    PolicyClinical Review Criteria Shoulder Arthroplasty
    Policy CodePolicy N/A
    Change TypeModified
    Effective DateAugust 1, 2026
    Last ReviewJun 9, 2026
    Next Review DateN/A
    Key ActionSubmit prior authorization for the procedure site of service and document that applicable medical-necessity criteria are met.
    SourceLink
    On This Page
    Medical Necessity CriteriaProcedure Codes and Clinical ThresholdsAuthorization and Documentation RequirementsShoulder Arthroplasty OverviewProcedure Definitions
    Anti-inflammatory medication ≥ 3 weeks; physical therapy within the last 12 months

    Medication may include oral or topical NSAIDs unless contraindicated and/or an appropriate intra-articular corticosteroid injection.

  1. Replacement is needed because of disabling pain for 3 months and functional disability in age-appropriate activities of daily living for 3 months.3 months of disabling pain and 3 months of functional disability
  2. The patient is capable of participating in required rehabilitation to achieve a positive outcome.
  3. Osteonecrosis of the humeral head.
  4. Periprosthetic shoulder infection, such as infection with substantial glenoid bone loss.
  5. Malignancy involving the glenohumeral joint or surrounding soft tissue that is amenable to resection and hemiarthroplasty.
  6. Glenohumeral osteoarthritis with an irreparable rotator cuff tear or due to rotator cuff arthropathy.
  7. BMI, diabetes, and nicotine/tobacco optimization requirements are satisfied or appropriately documented under the patient optimization criteria.
  8. >40% of humeral articular surface
  9. Failed reduction or malunion.
  10. When HbA1c is above goalDocument active medical management and HbA1c reduction over 3–6 months. If the target is not achieved, document adequate improvement efforts and shared decision-making; case-by-case medical-director review may apply.
    Nicotine/tobacco cessation
    Preferred statusNonsmoker.
    Required cessation or reductionBe nicotine/tobacco-free for at least 30 days before surgery or reduce nicotine/tobacco use by 90%.
    Program participationActive participation in a nicotine-cessation program is required. If reduction attempts are unsuccessful, document shared decision-making regarding surgical risk.
    Disabling pain and functional disability
    Disabling painAt least 3 months of disabling pain.
    Functional disabilityAt least 3 months of functional disability.
    Activities affectedThe functional disability must affect age-appropriate activities of daily living when required by the applicable indication.
    Anti-inflammatory medication
    Minimum durationAnti-inflammatory treatment must be tried for at least 3 weeks.
    Acceptable medication examplesOral or topical nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs, unless contraindicated; acetaminophen; or an appropriate intra-articular corticosteroid injection.
    Related conservative treatmentFor applicable indications, a physical-therapy trial within the last 12 months is also required unless the record documents why conservative treatment is not reasonable.
    Posterior humeral head subluxation
    Imaging thresholdPosterior humeral head subluxation greater than 50%.
    Acceptable imagingThe finding must be shown on x-rays or advanced imaging.
    Associated requirementThe patient must have an intact and functional deltoid muscle for this indication.
    • Anti-inflammatory treatment for at least 3 weeks: oral or topical NSAIDs unless contraindicated, acetaminophen when applicable, and/or an appropriate intra-articular corticosteroid injection.
    • A physical-therapy trial within the last 12 months, unless exempted.
    • Potentially acceptable exemptions include rapid progression or advancement of radiographic arthritis, rapid or progressive flexion contracture, or medical or social factors that make conservative treatment unsafe or infeasible.
    • For rheumatoid arthritis, document applicable disease-modifying antirheumatic drug treatment in addition to other nonoperative therapy.
    Documentation Required

    Subluxation: Document Six Weeks of Failed Therapy

    For posterior humeral head subluxation, document at least 6 weeks of failed nonoperative therapy before requesting the procedure.

    • Therapy must include physical therapy and anti-inflammatory medications and/or analgesics.
    • Also document imaging showing greater than 50% subluxation, an intact and functional deltoid muscle, and function-limiting pain interfering with age-appropriate activities of daily living for at least 3 months.
    Documentation Required

    Submit Required Clinical Notes

    Submit the last 6 months of clinical notes from the requesting provider and/or specialist to support medical necessity and allow review of the indication, treatment history, and optimization status.

    • Clinical notes should be current, legible, and include the relevant examination, imaging, symptoms, functional limitations, and prior treatment documentation.
    Documentation Required

    Support Medical Necessity

    Support medical necessity with documentation of the applicable indication, objective imaging, symptoms, functional limitations, duration, and treatment history. The record must show why the requested shoulder arthroplasty is needed and that the member can participate in required rehabilitation when applicable.

    • Indications may include advanced joint disease, osteonecrosis, proximal humerus fracture, massive or irreparable rotator cuff tear or cuff-deficient arthropathy, failed repair or prior arthroplasty, fracture or implant complication, infection, malignancy amenable to resection, rheumatoid arthritis, or other listed procedure-specific indications.
    • For advanced joint disease, describe radiographic destruction, severe joint-space narrowing or articular disease, erosion, inadequate bone stock, cystic changes, irregular joint surfaces, glenoid sclerosis or osteophytes, or a flattened or cystic humeral head as applicable.
    • Document at least 3 months of disabling pain and 3 months of functional disability in age-appropriate activities of daily living when required by the indication.
    • For reverse arthroplasty, document the specific qualifying indication; rheumatoid arthritis additionally requires positive radiographic findings and failed nonoperative therapy.
    • For fracture indications, identify the qualifying fracture pattern or complication, such as a displaced 3- or 4-part fracture, fracture-dislocation, anatomic-neck fracture, humeral-head-splitting or depression fracture, articular-surface involvement greater than 40%, failed reduction, or malunion.
    Documentation Required

    Document Medical Optimization

    Document medical optimization efforts and risk counseling when applicable, including weight, diabetes, nicotine or tobacco use, counseling, participation in programs, and shared decision-making regarding residual risk.

    • BMI should be below 40. If BMI is above 40, document active weight-loss efforts with sustained weight loss over 3–6 months or stable weight despite active participation in a weight-loss or exercise program, plus formal nutritional counseling.
    • If optimization is unsuccessful, document surgeon-patient shared decision-making showing understanding of the risks; BMI above 40 is a relative contraindication and may require case-by-case medical-director review.
    • Document no diabetes or HbA1c below 8. If HbA1c is above goal, document active medical management and reduction over 3–6 months; HbA1c above 8.0 is a relative contraindication and may require case-by-case review.
    • Document that the member is a nonsmoker, or document active nicotine-cessation participation and nicotine/tobacco abstinence for at least 30 days before surgery or a 90% reduction in use.
    • If nicotine or tobacco reduction is unsuccessful, document shared decision-making and understanding of risk; no change in use is a relative contraindication.
    Denial Risk

    Failure to Meet Procedure-Specific Criteria

    Requests may be denied or escalated when the procedure-specific indication or required medical-necessity criteria are not documented. Ensure the record supports the requested arthroplasty type rather than relying on a general diagnosis alone.

    • Denial risk includes absent qualifying imaging, symptoms, functional limitations, required duration of pain or disability, failed conservative treatment, or rehabilitation capability when applicable.
    • For posterior subluxation, missing greater-than-50% imaging findings, functional deltoid, 3 months of qualifying symptoms, or 6 weeks of failed nonoperative therapy does not meet the criteria.
    • For rheumatoid arthritis, missing radiographic findings or required nonoperative treatment may prevent approval.
    • For revision arthroplasty, document the qualifying complication, such as component instability, failed rotator cuff tendon, fracture or mechanical failure, glenoid erosion, infection, proximal migration, recurrent prosthetic dislocation unresponsive to nonsurgical care, aseptic loosening, or periprosthetic fracture.
    Denial Risk

    Unresolved Optimization Risk

    Unresolved optimization risks can result in denial, relative contraindication, or medical-director review. Document adequate efforts and the risk discussion whenever BMI, HbA1c, or nicotine/tobacco criteria are not within the preferred range.

    • BMI above 40 without documented weight-loss or exercise participation, formal nutritional counseling, and risk discussion may trigger review.
    • HbA1c above 8.0 without documented medical-management efforts and improvement over 3–6 months may trigger review.
    • Ongoing nicotine or tobacco use without the required cessation program, 30 days of abstinence, or 90% reduction may trigger review.
    • When optimization is unsuccessful, the record must document shared decision-making and the member's understanding of the increased risks.
    Denial Risk

    Insufficient Clinical Documentation

    Requests may lack sufficient support without the required last 6 months of clinical notes from the requesting provider and/or specialist. Include the records with the authorization submission rather than relying only on a diagnosis or procedure code.

    • Use the submitted notes to substantiate the indication, imaging review, pain and functional limitations, duration, conservative-treatment failure, optimization efforts, and risk counseling.
    Mechanical ball
    The ball is attached to the glenoid cup in the shoulder blade.
    Shoulder arthroplasty
    DefinitionShoulder arthroplasty is replacement of the shoulder joint component or components covered by the guideline.
    Covered procedure typesThe guideline covers total shoulder arthroplasty, reverse total shoulder arthroplasty, and revision shoulder arthroplasty.
    Joint configurationThe procedure involves replacement of components of the shoulder joint’s ball-and-socket structure.