Loading...

    Explore
    • Policy Monitoring
    • Live Policy Feed
    • Billing Codes
    • Healthcare Providers
    • Health Insurance Payers
    • States
    • Service Lines
    • Taxonomy Codes
    Lookup tools
    • Billing Code Lookup
    • CPT Modifier Lookup
    • Provider Taxonomy Code Lookup
    • Healthcare Provider & Facility Lookup
    • Health Insurance Payer Lookup
    • Payer Contact Directory

    Policy & Benchmark Tools

    • Prior Authorization Lookup
    • Coverage Criteria Lookup
    • Timely Filing Lookup
    • Billing Code Reimbursement Rates
    • Payer Comparison Dashboard
    • Facility Comparison Dashboard
    • All tools

    Company

    • About OpenPayer
    • Data Sources
    • Trek Health
    OpenPayerby Trek Health
    LinkedInYouTube

    © 2026 Trek Health. All rights reserved.

    OpenPayer is built and maintained by Trek Health.

    v1.0.31
    OpenPayerPolicy UpdatesClinical/Medical PolicyUpper Ohio Valley Coverage Update | OpenPayer
    Ask Trek AI about this page
    CurrentHealth Plan of the Upper Ohio Valley, Inc.Policy 18796704

    Medical Necessity Determination Policy for Medicare-Covered Services Without Established Criteria

    Customize your policy alerts

    Sign up for healthplanofupperohiovalley Policy 18796704 alerts

    Get alerted when Policy 18796704 changes without checking for updates manually.

    Monitor payer policy activity

    Receive email alerts as soon as relevant payer policies are published or updated.

    This policy governs case-by-case medical necessity reviews for Health Plan Medicare Advantage and D-SNP enrollees when applicable Medicare or internal coverage criteria are incomplete or do not exist. It applies to pre-service prior authorization, concurrent review, and post-service claims review for basic Medicare benefits.

    Policy Summary
    PayerHealth Plan of the Upper Ohio Valley, Inc.
    PolicyMedical Necessity Determination Policy for Medicare-Covered Services Without Established Criteria
    Policy CodePolicy 18796704
    Change TypeNo material clinical or coverage change
    Effective DateOct 23, 2025
    Next Review DateOct 23, 2026
    Key ActionFirst determine whether an applicable Medicare regulation, NCD, or LCD establishes coverage criteria before applying internal criteria or individualized reasonable-and-necessary standards.
    SourceLink
    POLICY UPDATE CHANGES

    No material clinical or coverage changes in this revision.

    3Review stages covered
    5Core reasonable-and-necessary considerations
    3Minimum clinical documentation categories

    OpenPayer is powered by Trek Health's payer performance platform. Trek continuously ingests, validates, and normalizes Transparency in Coverage data alongside payer policies and other commercial payer data to create a structured payer intelligence foundation. OpenPayer uses this foundation to deliver personalized search results, dynamically generated policy pages, and tailored policy monitoring based on each user's payers, specialties, billing codes, and areas of interest. The same intelligence powers broader payer performance workflows, including reimbursement benchmarking, contract evaluation, payer negotiations, and financial decision-making.

    3Acceptable peer-reviewed evidence types
    100%Approved medically necessary course authorized
    6Adverse-determination triggers

    Individualized Medical Necessity Criteria

    Coverage Criteria Hierarchy

    Apply the highest available coverage authority before using individualized reasonable-and-necessary review.

    Coverage hierarchy

    • Established criteria source: An applicable Medicare regulation, NCD, or LCD exists and is applied.

      Medicare criteria take precedence.

    • Internal criteria source: No Medicare criteria exist, but applicable internal coverage criteria exist and are applied.

      Internal criteria may be used only when Medicare criteria do not exist or do not fully define coverage.

    • Individualized review: Neither Medicare nor internal criteria fully define coverage, so the request is evaluated under reasonable-and-necessary standards.

      This policy applies to the gap scenario.

    Reasonable and Necessary Service Criteria

    The service must meet ALL reasonable-and-necessary requirements.

    Reasonable and necessary requirements

    • Benefit and clinical purpose: The service falls within a Medicare benefit category and is furnished according to accepted standards of medical practice for diagnosing or treating the condition or improving function.
    • Safety and effectiveness: The service is safe and effective for the intended use and is not experimental or investigational.

      Routine costs of qualifying clinical trial services meeting the Clinical Trials NCD are an exception to the experimental or investigational limitation.

    • Appropriate delivery: The duration, frequency, and setting are appropriate; the service is ordered and delivered by qualified personnel; and it meets but does not exceed the patient's medical needs.

      The service should not be furnished primarily for the convenience of the patient, provider, or supplier.

    Approval Criteria

    Approve when ALL approval conditions are met.

    Approval conditions

    • Covered benefit: The service falls within a Medicare-covered benefit category.
    • No statutory exclusion: The service is not statutorily excluded.
    • Medical necessity supported: Clinical documentation and medical necessity review establish that the service meets reasonable-and-necessary criteria.

    Adverse Determination Criteria

    Coverage cannot be authorized if ANY adverse condition applies.

    Adverse determination conditions

    • Unsafe or ineffective: The service is not generally accepted as safe and effective or lacks proven safety and efficacy based on peer-reviewed literature.
    • Experimental or investigational: The service is experimental or investigational, outside the qualifying clinical trial exception.
    • Not individually necessary: The service is not medically necessary for the specific patient.
    • Excessive or inappropriate utilization: The service is furnished at an inappropriate level, duration, or frequency.

    Statutorily excluded services are not eligible for approval under this policy, even when requested clinical documentation supports the service.

    This policy does not override or bypass established Medicare coverage criteria or internal clinical policies. It applies only when fully established Medicare or internal criteria do not exist.

    A service is not medically necessary when the available evidence does not support reasonable-and-necessary treatment for the specific enrollee. The determination considers whether the request is supported by the enrollee's clinical circumstances and documentation.

    A service is not medically necessary when furnished at an inappropriate duration, frequency, level, or setting, or when it does not align with accepted standards of medical practice. Services must be appropriate to the enrollee's medical needs and condition.

    A service is not medically necessary when it is not shown to be safe and effective, lacks proven safety or efficacy in peer-reviewed literature, or is experimental or investigational. The limitation on experimental or investigational services does not apply to routine costs of qualifying clinical trial services that meet the Clinical Trials NCD.

    Review, Submission, and Denial-Risk Actions

    Note

    All Review Stages

    Apply this policy to every medical-necessity review stage, including review before, during, and after the service is provided.

    • Pre-service: prior authorization before the service is provided.
    • Concurrent review: case management during ongoing treatment.
    • Post-service: claims review after the service has been delivered.
    Billing Rule

    Follow the Coverage Criteria Hierarchy

    Check coverage criteria in the required hierarchy before applying any other standard. Use established Medicare criteria whenever they exist; do not substitute proprietary or external criteria unless Medicare policy explicitly recognizes them.

    • First, check applicable Medicare statutes, regulations, and coverage policies.

    Policy Scope and Medicare Context

    Medicare-covered services must fall within a Medicare benefit category and be reasonable and necessary to diagnose or treat an illness or injury. Coverage also includes services that improve the function of a malformed body member when the applicable Medicare requirements are met.

    Key Coverage Definitions

    Reasonable and necessary
    Medicare benefit categoryThe service falls within a Medicare benefit category.
    SafetyThe service is safe for the intended use.
    EffectivenessThe service is effective for the intended use.
    Appropriate deliveryThe service is appropriately delivered, including appropriate duration, frequency, setting, and qualified personnel.
    Medical needThe service is medically needed to diagnose or treat illness or injury or improve function, and meets but does not exceed the patient's medical needs.
    Comparative benefitThe service is at least as beneficial as an existing, available, and medically appropriate alternative.
    Policy Summary
    PayerHealth Plan of the Upper Ohio Valley, Inc.
    PolicyMedical Necessity Determination Policy for Medicare-Covered Services Without Established Criteria
    Policy CodePolicy 18796704
    Change TypeNo material clinical or coverage change
    Effective DateOct 23, 2025
    Next Review DateOct 23, 2026
    Key ActionFirst determine whether an applicable Medicare regulation, NCD, or LCD establishes coverage criteria before applying internal criteria or individualized reasonable-and-necessary standards.
    SourceLink
    On This Page
    Individualized Medical Necessity CriteriaReview, Submission, and Denial-Risk ActionsPolicy Scope and Medicare ContextKey Coverage Definitions
  1. Individual clinical consistency: The service is consistent with the symptoms or diagnosis of the illness or injury under treatment and is supported by the enrollee's clinical circumstances.

    Consider medical history, diagnosis, functional status, physician recommendations, and supporting documentation.

  2. Comparative benefit: The service is at least as beneficial as an existing, available, and medically appropriate alternative.
  3. Standards or setting conflict: The service does not align with accepted medical standards or is provided in an inappropriate setting based on the patient's medical condition.
  4. Then apply an applicable National Coverage Determination (NCD).
  5. Then apply an applicable Local Coverage Determination (LCD).
  6. If no Medicare criteria exist, use internal coverage criteria.
  7. If neither Medicare nor internal criteria exist, assess the request under reasonable-and-necessary standards.
  8. Documentation Required

    Verify Benefit Category and Delivery Conditions

    Identify the Medicare benefit category and verify that the requested service satisfies all applicable delivery conditions before completing the review.

    • Confirm the applicable category, such as physician services, durable medical equipment, diagnostic tests, drugs, biologics, or inpatient medical services.
    • Verify the setting, duration, frequency, and level of care are appropriate.
    • Confirm the service is ordered and administered by qualified personnel.
    • Verify applicable delivery, coding, and other Medicare benefit conditions.

    Unsupported block type: documentation

    Documentation Required

    Provide Clinical Records and Treatment History

    Submit sufficient clinical records for the reviewer to evaluate the enrollee-specific need and response to treatment.

    • Physician orders for the requested care or treatment.
    • Relevant diagnoses, medical history, functional status, and other supporting records.
    • Progress notes describing the enrollee's response to prior treatments.
    • Laboratory results, test results, and other relevant medical evidence.
    Documentation Required

    Submit Accessible Peer-Reviewed Evidence

    Support the request with accessible, published evidence demonstrating clinical benefit and acceptance by the broader medical community. Proprietary information that is not publicly accessible will not be considered.

    • Randomized controlled trials, cohort studies, or systematic reviews or meta-analyses with clear and consistent results published in peer-reviewed journals.
    • CMS-recognized clinical literature meeting Medicare standards for demonstrating reasonable and necessary care.
    • Evidence must support safety, effectiveness, clinical benefit, and general acceptance beyond a small group of providers.
    Documentation Required

    Document the Evidence Analysis

    Document the evidence analysis used for the determination, including the service, evidence reviewed, dates considered, and the scientific or clinical rationale supporting the decision.

    • Provide a comprehensive summary of the item or service.
    • Identify the specific evidence and date considered.
    • Explain the scientific rationale for the determination.
    • When relevant, document external professional opinions and FDA regulatory status.
    Denial Risk

    Safety, Efficacy, or Acceptance Deficiency

    Coverage cannot be authorized when the record does not establish that the service is safe, effective, and accepted for the condition or setting under review.

    • The service is not generally accepted by the medical community as safe and effective.
    • Peer-reviewed literature does not establish safety or efficacy.
    • The service is experimental or investigational, except as permitted for a qualifying clinical trial.
    • The evidence does not demonstrate a proven clinical benefit.
    Denial Risk

    Patient-Specific Necessity or Utilization Mismatch

    Coverage may be denied when the service is not reasonable and necessary for the specific enrollee or when utilization exceeds the patient's clinical needs.

    • The service is not medically necessary for the specific patient based on the diagnosis, history, functional status, or supporting records.
    • The duration, frequency, or level of care is not clinically appropriate.
    • The service is furnished primarily for the convenience of the patient, provider, or supplier.
    Denial Risk

    Inconsistent Standards or Inappropriate Setting

    The service must be furnished in accordance with accepted standards of medical practice, at an appropriate site of care, and with correct coding and qualified ordering or administration.

    • The service does not align with accepted medical standards for treating the condition or improving the function of a malformed body member.
    • The setting is inappropriate for the patient's medical condition.
    • The service is not ordered or administered by qualified personnel or is coded incorrectly.
    Denial Risk

    No Medicare Benefit or Statutory Exclusion

    Do not approve a request unless it falls within a Medicare-covered benefit category and is not statutorily excluded. A service outside Medicare benefit coverage or subject to a statutory exclusion cannot be authorized under this policy.

    • Confirm that a Medicare Part A or Part B benefit category applies.
    • Confirm that the service is not statutorily excluded.
    • If covered and not excluded, approval still requires reasonable-and-necessary support through clinical documentation and medical review.
    • When approved, authorize the entire medically necessary course of treatment.
    Incomplete coverage criteria
    Additional interpretationAdditional criteria are required to interpret or supplement general Medicare coverage provisions for consistent medical necessity determinations.
    Flexible NCD or LCDAn applicable National Coverage Determination or Local Coverage Determination permits coverage flexibility beyond its specified indications.
    No applicable Medicare criteriaNo applicable Medicare statute, regulation, National Coverage Determination, or Local Coverage Determination defines the coverage criteria.
    Service without established criteria
    Medicare criteriaApplicable Medicare statutes, regulations, National Coverage Determinations, and Local Coverage Determinations do not fully define the coverage circumstances.
    Internal policyAn established internal clinical policy does not fully define the coverage circumstances.
    Review approachThe request is evaluated through an individualized medical necessity determination aligned with evidence-based medicine and Medicare's statutory framework.