Loading...

    Explore
    • Policy Monitoring
    • Live Policy Feed
    • Billing Codes
    • Healthcare Providers
    • Health Insurance Payers
    • States
    • Service Lines
    • Taxonomy Codes
    Lookup tools
    • Billing Code Lookup
    • CPT Modifier Lookup
    • Provider Taxonomy Code Lookup
    • Healthcare Provider & Facility Lookup
    • Health Insurance Payer Lookup
    • Payer Contact Directory

    Policy & Benchmark Tools

    • Prior Authorization Lookup
    • Coverage Criteria Lookup
    • Timely Filing Lookup
    • Billing Code Reimbursement Rates
    • Payer Comparison Dashboard
    • Facility Comparison Dashboard
    • All tools

    Company

    • About OpenPayer
    • Data Sources
    • Trek Health
    OpenPayerby Trek Health
    LinkedInYouTube

    © 2026 Trek Health. All rights reserved.

    OpenPayer is built and maintained by Trek Health.

    v1.0.31
    OpenPayerPolicy UpdatesReimbursement/Payment PolicySanford Health Plan claim edits policy update | Op…
    Ask Trek AI about this page
    Currentsanford health planPolicy N/A

    Claim Edits (Optum CES automated claim editing and mappings)

    Customize your policy alerts

    Sign up for all sanford health plan policy alerts

    Know when sanford health plan releases new policies or updates existing guidance.

    Monitor payer policy activity

    Receive email alerts as soon as relevant payer policies are published or updated.

    Defines Sanford Health Plan's automated claim editing approach using the Optum Claims Editing System (CES) and the specific CES edits applied to professional and institutional claims; affects participating and non-participating providers submitting claims to Sanford Health Plan.

    Policy Summary
    Payersanford health plan
    PolicyClaim Edits (Optum CES automated claim editing and mappings)
    Policy CodePolicy N/A
    Change TypeNo material change
    Effective DateJul 15, 2020
    Last ReviewJul 15, 2020
    Next Review DateN/A
    Key ActionAuthorizations or referrals do not override claim edits; edits applied to claims are provider adjustments and are not billable to the member.
    SourceLink
    POLICY UPDATE CHANGES

    No material clinical or coverage changes in this revision.

    Optum CESClaims editing system used
    Participating & non-participatingProvider applicability
    7/15/2020Document last updated
    modifier issuesCommon edit type

    OpenPayer is powered by Trek Health's payer performance platform. Trek continuously ingests, validates, and normalizes Transparency in Coverage data alongside payer policies and other commercial payer data to create a structured payer intelligence foundation. OpenPayer uses this foundation to deliver personalized search results, dynamically generated policy pages, and tailored policy monitoring based on each user's payers, specialties, billing codes, and areas of interest. The same intelligence powers broader payer performance workflows, including reimbursement benchmarking, contract evaluation, payer negotiations, and financial decision-making.

    bundled/not payableFrequent recurring reason

    Claim Edit Coverage Rules

    Claim edit criteria and mappings

    Sanford applies automated edits to claims; these edits determine accept/adjust/deny outcomes and map to CES and 835 reason codes.

    Edits are applied to claims received from both participating and non-participating providers.
    Authorizations or referrals do not override claim edits; edits applied to claims are considered provider adjustments and are not billable to the member.
    CES edit codes map to Explanation of Payment and 835 Claim Adjustment Reason Codes (examples include CES2/CO-16, CES19/CO-19, M50/CO-16).
    Enhancements and new edits may be implemented periodically; the Optum Claims Editing System is used to enforce coding standards and apply industry-standard edits (NCCI, AMA, CMS).

    Examples of rule-triggered outcomes

    • Device-dependent procedures reported without required device codes or ambulance mileage may trigger edits that deny or adjust the claim.
    • Diagnosis inconsistent with patient age is flagged by CES (e.g., CES9) and mapped to CO reason codes for correction or denial.
    • Duplicate procedure or frequency edits may adjust or deny claims when duplicate reporting or frequency limits are exceeded.
    CES edit values and mappings are used operationally to map to downstream payment or denial outcomes; providers will receive the mapped CES and 835/CO codes on the remittance advice.

    Principal diagnosis-related edits

    Mappings where missing/incomplete/invalid principal diagnosis (CES15 / CO-16) lead to various denials or restrictions:

    If CES15 / CO-16 is triggered for missing, incomplete, or invalid principal diagnosis, the claim may map to modifier-denial outcomes (CES49 / CO-4) when specific ICMf values indicate missing or inconsistent modifiers.

    Specific mapped outcomes

    • Certain ICMf values map CES15 to CES49/CO-4 resulting in denial for missing/invalid modifier.
    • Some ICMf values map CES15 to EXPER/CO-55 resulting in denial as experimental/investigational (not covered).
    • Other ICMf values map CES15 to 119B/CO-119 for benefit maximum or frequency exceeded denials (e.g., typical daily or monthly frequency limits).
    Multiple specific ICMf values (e.g., IM27f, LNM, M62, MFD, MFX1 and others listed) are associated with these CES15 mappings and determine the downstream CO/denial codes.

    Discharge information edits

    Discharge and provider data element validations:

    If CES16 / CO-16 is triggered for missing, incomplete, or invalid discharge information, providers may see downstream edits requiring a referring provider name (CES17 / CO-16).
    Missing or invalid discharge information can require patient reason for visit data (CES36 / CO-16) or trigger missing/invalid revenue code denials (M50 / CO-16).

    Surgical and provider relationship edits triggered by discharge data

    • Team or assistant surgeon rules may be enforced (CES55 / CO-54; EX27), including denial of multiple assistant surgeries or assistant/co-surgeon not allowed for the procedure.
    • Missing discharge details can flag bundled procedure outcomes (CES44 / CO-234) or trigger Medicaid add-on primary-procedure flags (CES38 / CO-B15).
    CES16 mappings may also result in modifier-related denials (CES49 / CO-4) when discharge data indicates missing or inconsistent modifiers.

    Bundling and NDC-related edits

    Bundle and place-of-service or interpretation related edits:

    When a procedure is determined to be bundled (CES44 / CO-234), it is considered not separately payable and may map to denial codes indicating the procedure is included in another service.

    Modifier GK/GZ and related outcomes

    • Modifiers GK or GZ map to multiple outcomes including 'not billable to the member' (NOPAT / CO-45), physician interpretation only policy (CES31 / CO-96), and add-on reported without primary (CES1 / CO-107).
    • Use of GK/GZ can also trigger location/specialist restrictions, team-surgeon prohibitions, and bundled/not-separately-payable mappings (CES29 -> CES44 / CO-234).
    When an NDC (or UIN/NDC mapping) is required but missing for a bundled procedure, the edit maps to deny NDC required (M119) or similar non-payment outcomes.
    Examples of procedure/UIN mappings (e.g., 006IPC = Invalid Procedure Code; APP = laparoscopic appendectomy at time of other major procedure) can produce CES44 bundle mappings and CO-16/CO-234 outcomes.

    Denial/Non-payment criteria

    Edits that lead to denial or non-payment when specific conditions are met:

    If a procedure triggers CES44 / CO-234 it is considered bundled and not separately payable; the claim line will be denied or not paid separately (CO-234 mappings).
    If CES49 / CO-4 is triggered for missing or invalid modifiers, the claim may be denied or require correction; this is a common downstream denial mapping.
    If CES6 / CO-16 is triggered for device-dependent procedures reported without required device codes or ambulance mileage, the claim will be denied (device code required).
    Add-on codes (CES1 / CO-107) reported without the required primary procedure will be denied or rejected until corrected or the primary is present on the claim.

    Global period, qualifying service, and frequency outcomes

    • Services performed during an active global period or without required qualifying services are considered included in another payment and may be denied (CES50/CES53 / CO-97 or CO-97/CO-107 mappings).

    Optum CES Edit Codes and Code Mappings

    Sample Optum CES edit codes and explanationsmixed
    017IBPCES2: Inappropriate Specification of Bilateral Procedure
    023BDSCES19: Invalid Date/Missing Service Date
    041IRCM50: Missing/Invalid Revenue Code
    048RRHM20: Submission of revenue code requires a HCPCS code
    04AAGECES9: Diagnosis is inconsistent with patients age
    Examples of UIN/procedure code mappingsmixed
    006IPCInvalid Procedure Code (mapped to CES13 / CO-16)
    APPLaparoscopic Appendectomy at Time of Other Major Procedure (mapped to CES33)
    Modifier GK/GZ mappingsModifierCovered
    GK/GZModifiers GK or GZ have multiple mapped outcomes including not billable (CO-45), physician interpretation only policy (CO-96), add-on without primary (CO-107), team surgeons not permitted (CO-54).
    Frequent claim edit reason mappingsmixed
    CES44 / CO-234Procedure code is bundled and not separately payable / This procedure is not paid separately
    CES49 / CO-4Missing or invalid modifier / The procedure code is inconsistent with the modifier used or a required modifier is missing
    CES6 / CO-16Claim lacks required Device Code / Device-dependent procedure reported without Device Code
    Add-on / qualifying / global period editsmixed
    CES1 / CO-107Add-on code reported without required primary procedure code / The related or qualifying claim/service was not identified on this claim
    CES24 / CO-B16Claim lacks required qualifying visit/patient code / 'New Patient' qualifications were not met
    CES50 / CO-97Service performed during active global period and not allowed / Benefit included in payment for another service
    Facility outpatient services outside approval period
    Mapped reasonFacility outpatient services provided outside of approval period -> CO-198 / CES41 and multiple downstream CES/CO mappings (e.g., CES3/CO-16 units >1 with modifier 50; CES19/CO-107 add-on without primary; CES24/CO-B16 missing qualifying visit code; CES6/CO-16 missing device code)
    Example: device code missingCES41 -> CES6 / CO-198 -> CO-16: Claim lacks required device code
    Example: add-on without primaryCES41 -> CES19 / CO-198 -> CO-107: Add-on code reported without required primary procedure code
    Example: missing qualifying visitCES41 -> CES24 / CO-198 -> CO-B16: Claim lacks required qualifying visit/patient code
    Example: principal diagnosis issuesCES41 -> CES15 / CO-198 -> CO-16: Missing/incomplete/invalid principal diagnosis

    Provider Responsibilities & Denial Risk

    Prior Authorization

    Authorizations/referrals do not override CES edits

    Authorizations or referrals do not override claim edits. Edits applied to claims are considered to be a provider adjustment and not billable to the member.

    Denial Risk

    Report required and consistent modifiers (CES49/CO-4) to avoid denial

    Claims with missing or inconsistent modifiers will be denied under CES49 / CO-4 and can map to downstream outcomes such as 'This service is not billable to the member' (NOPAT / CO-45) or 'Claim lacks required qualifying visit/patient code' (CES24 / CO-B16); correct and consistent modifier reporting is required to avoid denial.

    • CES49 / CO-4 = Deny missing/inconsistent modifier; may map to CO-45 (not billable to member).
    • Missing/inconsistent modifiers can also map to CES24 / CO-B16 (lacks required qualifying visit/patient code) or other CES mappings shown in the modifier matrix.

    Terms and Edit Code Definitions

    Optum CES
    DefinitionOptum® Claims Editing System (CES) - automated claims editing engine Sanford Health Plan uses to enforce coding standards and edits
    ScopeApplies to professional and institutional claims; edits are applied to claims from both participating and non-participating providers
    MaintenanceEnhancements and new edits may be implemented periodically; document updated as of 7/15/2020
    Provider adjustment
    Provider adjustment ruleEdits applied to claims are considered provider adjustments and are not billable to the member
    Authorization impactAuthorizations or referrals do not override claim edits
    Policy Summary
    Payersanford health plan
    PolicyClaim Edits (Optum CES automated claim editing and mappings)
    Policy CodePolicy N/A
    Change TypeNo material change
    Effective DateJul 15, 2020
    Last ReviewJul 15, 2020
    Next Review DateN/A
    Key ActionAuthorizations or referrals do not override claim edits; edits applied to claims are provider adjustments and are not billable to the member.
    SourceLink
    On This Page
    Claim Edit Coverage RulesOptum CES Edit Codes and Code MappingsProvider Responsibilities & Denial RiskTerms and Edit Code Definitions
  1. Benefit maximums and frequency limits (119B / CO-119) apply and may cause denials when exceeded (typical daily or 30/90-day limits).
  2. Diagnosis and age mismatches (CES9 / CO-9) may result in denials or requests for correction when the diagnosis is inconsistent with the patient’s age.
    Benefit max exceeded
    Mapped denialBenefit max exceeded -> 119B / CO-119: Deny benefit max exceeded
    Associated outcomes119B/CO-119 can map to CES53/CO-97 (performed during active global period), CES39/CO-96 (HCPCS not reportable on professional claim), or M52/CO-16 (missing statement from date)
    Frequency interplayBenefit max exceeded edits may be triggered by daily or monthly frequency rules (e.g., typical daily frequency exceeded -> CO-119)
    Frequency limits
    Common frequency limitsFrequency limits include typical daily or 30/90-day device frequency rules that can trigger CO-119 / 119B denials when exceeded (e.g., maximum frequency one per day; 30-day cardiac device frequency)
    Example: daily limitCO-119: Maximum frequency, one per day exceeded (Typical Daily frequency exceeded)
    Example: 30/90-day device limitsDevice-dependent procedures (e.g., cardiac device) subject to 30-day or 90-day frequency rules -> 119B / CO-119 when exceeded
    Related editsFrequency violations may also map to missing discharge info or bundled procedure edits depending on context (e.g., CES16 / CES44 interactions)
    Documentation Required

    Include complete discharge and provider information (CES16/CO-16)

    Missing, incomplete, or invalid discharge information (CES16 / CO-16) triggers downstream edits including missing/invalid referring provider name, patient reason for visit required, missing/invalid revenue code, team/assistant surgeon restrictions, and Medicaid add-on primary procedure flags; submit complete discharge and provider data elements to prevent these edits.

    • CES16 = CES17 / CO-16: Missing/incomplete/invalid referring provider name.
    • CES16 = CES36 / CO-16: Patient reason for visit required.
    • CES16 = M50 / CO-16: Deny missing/invalid revenue code.
    • CES16 = CES55 / CO-54: Team surgeons not permitted / multiple assistant surgery not allowed.
    • CES16 = CES38: Medicaid add-on procedure - primary procedure flagged.
    Billing Rule

    Submit associated primary/qualifying procedures and observe global periods

    Procedures that lack an associated payable procedure on the same claim or that occur during a global period or without required qualifying services will be adjusted or denied (e.g., CES44 / CO-234 → CES28 / CO-16 lacks payable procedure; CES1 / CO-107 and CES53 / CO-97 indicate add-on/ global-period conflicts). Ensure related primary procedures and qualifying services are submitted on the same claim and respect global periods.

    • CES44 / CO-234 = CES28 / CO-16: Lacks payable procedure that must be submitted on the same claim.
    • Add-on codes (CES1 / CO-107) reported without the required primary procedure will be denied.
    • Services performed during an active global period (CES53 / CO-97) or within a global period may be excluded from separate payment.
    Denial Risk

    Include required device codes/mileage for device-dependent procedures (CES6/CO-16)

    Device-dependent procedures reported without the required device code or ambulance mileage will be denied (CES6 / CO-16); include the required device code(s) or mileage to avoid denial and related edits.

    • CES6 / CO-16: Claim lacks required Device Code — will map to denials or other edits (e.g., CES39, CO-96, CES53, CO-97).
    • Missing device codes can also trigger age/diagnosis, frequency, or benefit-maximum edits (e.g., CES9 / CO-9, 119B / CO-119).
    ApplicabilityProvider adjustments apply to claims from both participating and non-participating providers
    CES49 / CO-4 (Missing/Inconsistent Modifier)
    Edit code mappingCES49 / CO-4: Deny missing/inconsistent or missing/invalid modifier (common downstream denial)
    Associated outcomesCES49/CO-4 can map to invalid procedure code (CES8/CO-181), care plan oversight (CES42/CO-151), benefit max exceeded (119B/CO-119), or missing/incomplete/invalid procedure code (CES4/CO-16)
    Provider actionClaims with missing or inconsistent modifiers must be corrected; modifier errors are not billable to member and may lead to denial
    CES44 / CO-234
    Edit code mappingCES44 / CO-234: Procedure code is bundled and not separately payable
    Typical resultWhen CES44/CO-234 applies, the procedure is considered bundled and not paid separately; may also map to M119 (NDC required) if drug NDC missing
    ExamplesMappings include invalid procedure code outcomes (CES13/CO-16) and specific UIN mappings such as APP (laparoscopic appendectomy) where bundling rules apply
    Bundled procedure (CES44 / CO-234)
    Bundled procedure definitionCES44 / CO-234: Procedure code is bundled and not separately payable; this procedure is not paid separately
    Payment consequenceEdits flagging a procedure as bundled result in denial or non-payment for that line item
    Related mappingsBundled-procedure edits may also trigger NDC-required denials (M119) or be linked to invalid HCPCS/procedure code outcomes (CES13/CO-16)
    Modifier error (CES49 / CO-4)
    Modifier error descriptionCES49 / CO-4: Missing or invalid modifier; the procedure code is inconsistent with the modifier used or a required modifier is missing
    Common impactsModifier errors can lead to denials for invalid procedure code, care plan oversight, benefit maximums, or missing procedure information (e.g., CES8/CO-181; 119B/CO-119; CES4/CO-16)
    RemediationProvider must correct or resubmit claim with the proper modifier to avoid denial; modifier-related edits are enforced by Optum CES
    Device-dependent procedure (CES6 / CO-16)
    Edit code mappingCES6 / CO-16: Claim lacks required device code for device-dependent procedures
    Typical triggersDevice-dependent procedures reported without device or mileage codes will be denied or adjusted (e.g., 092DDP mappings) and may also map to frequency/benefit limits (119B/CO-119)
    Related consequencesMissing device codes can also surface as HCPCS/reporting issues or global period conflicts (e.g., CES39, CES53) depending on context